Tonali is a Gattuso- Pirlo hybrid. He possesses nowhere near the passing range of Pirlo, but he's got more grinta and hustle. Again, he'd be a very important piece for us, but we need a WC presence in midfield in addition to Tonali if we are serious about winning the CL while CR7 is still here.
That's why I said sacrificing Pjanic to bring in both Pogba and Tonali wouldn't be such a terrible thing. Ramsey, Pogba, Bentancur, Rabiot, Tonali, with Berna (if we can't sell him) as a 6th choice CM option is a very impressive midfield lineup.
Tonalli in my eyes is like a verrati type regista, like you said, a hybrid of DM with technique to dribble and good pass range. He is a must buy imo, just in case he becomes the next best thing for italy, he looks very talented. We should not hesitate on this one.
About pogba, i had my doubts but ill be honest, after seeing the reinassence of higuain and dybala.... I have got new faith. Lemme explain.
I think that a big part of dybalas and higuain resurgence is because they both have experienced how ugly a career could go if you dont put oyurself together and work for it. In higuains case, he was on paradise here, and then got mistreated. After being in a year of undeserved purgatory, he returned here as a reject... but had the will to prove wrong the board even when he was being told to get out everyday of the preseason. I think this hardened his will so much that today the guy is reborn.
Dybala had 2 ugly last seasons under allegri. Bad performances and badblood between him and the coach. Things escalated so much that in the end the board decided to get rid of both. Dybala was shown the door multiple times this last summer without him even kowing he was getting sold. This was like the ultimate salt on the wound for him.
This situation made him mature and rethink about what was happening on his career. So he shaked off his issues and decided it was time to get control of his career once again... showing the board why they bought him in first place. This ugly experience made him grow.
All this said, to get to the pogba case:
In his last season here, the guy was a primadonna. He had the 10, he had no seniours above him on midfield to guide him. He believed he was all that. His performances dipped and ultimately he decided he was too big for this team and wanted the manchester glamour and money. After 3 seasons, i think he and raiola realized the shit they got themselves in. Pogba has been thru hell in this campaigns and i think this could have make him mature, just like dybala.
He cant take things for granted and maybe he has realized that time is ticking and need to get serious.
In the juventus enviroment, he can shine this time...above all because he doesn need to carry the burden of the responsability of being te big fish. Sarri could guide him to return to his best.