I dont want to cut him too short, but even tho his midfield approach and pragmatic defense/ tactical sense was very good, his attacking in Milan had the same limitations and overall issues we are having now. He needs to impose his style upfront like he does in the rest and build effective gameplan into it, but he couldnt there after Ibra left who he built it entirely around to both create AND score. Midfield was stacked with hardworkers that followed orders (no room for playmakers there, just DMs or box to box types) and attack was set on relying on individual decisiveness and nothing else. When that top quality individual clutch ability is not there anymore, then you start to see the cracks in the approach.
It was more issues with Milan, like losing dressing room etc. But essentially the limitations became clearer when he couldnt rely on that type of decisiveness anymore. Had to see more limited or less proven attackers who need more of a gameplan to function struggling often vs lesser opponents. He still did well in bigger (CL) games where was seen more of an underdog and his overall tactical preparedness and bunkering/adaptive style could come handy in games the players were pumped for. But those conditions arent there in the weekly games vs random league opponents that requires you to take the game to the opponents. The all too predictable wing it approach with zero creativity, where you saw likes of Boateng think he is a true nr 10 and try to do it all himself offensively backfired.
Huge difference in quality, but it kinda reminds me of how Pogba is struggling for us right now, since he is the only midfielder we have thats supposed to make things happen offensively, and he doesnt seem to be equipped for it just to figure things out on his own. Or wait, there is Cuadrado, but that dude doesnt need coaching...Its no suprise he is the new player who immediately just went about his usual way of taking it to the opponents. This dude doesnt need tactics or collective gameplan like most of the rest due to get the best out of them. He is simple, in any system, if you give him the license just to take the ball and beat your man, thats all he will do all day every day, regardless if he is being effective or not in end product. He failed in Chelsea, mostly, besides the very little minutes he got, because he was expected to do alot of tactical and rigid work that he isnt suited for Under Mourinho. The very fact we are relying so heavily on him right now is very worrisome, even if I love the dude to bits already, he is an absolute treat, aslong as he stops shooting...