Mafia 2020 - Find the carrier (21 Viewers)

Völler

Always spot on
May 6, 2012
23,091
Ok, lets entertain that.

The real D and a G write to the BG that they're the D. Since the BG gives 3 hours for the D to come out, once these 3 hours are over and the BG realizes that 2 claimed to be the D, he doesn't tell neither of them who's the jailer. That makes it harder for the real D to investigate tonight, but at least the BG knows that one of the two is a G and it gives him some room to operate tomorrow.
It will definitely give the BG some room to operate tomorrow, but how will he be able to use it? He can't reveal to the rest of the game which two players that contacted him.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Völler

Always spot on
May 6, 2012
23,091
What are your guys views on Osman?
He seems a little suspicious to me, but I can’t put my finger why.
Besides the no lynch strategy he hasn't really contributed with anything besides a few stupid questions. It's very convenient for you to bring his name up just after he has been jailed though. :D
 

Alen

Ѕenior Аdmin
Apr 2, 2007
53,907
It will definitely give the BG some room to operate tomorrow, but how will he be able to use it? He can't reveal to the rest of the game which two players that contacted him.
It depends who the BG is and how good he can play the game. Imagine it's Janna :D The BG would have played with the jailer and something would have came out.
Now it's too late, I guess, because the jailer made his move. And I don't think the Gs would have acted as the D on day 1.
 

campionesidd

Senior Member
Mar 16, 2013
16,789
Besides the no lynch strategy he hasn't really contributed with anything besides a few stupid questions. It's very convenient for you to bring his name up just after he has been jailed though. :D
his posts just seem a little off to me. Cerval is still my top choice though. I had my doubts about Mr Chocolate but he’s answered my questions well so he’s off the hook for now.
 

piotrr

Мodеrator
Sep 13, 2011
34,009
We are 12 people playing.
Right now we're 9 Cs and 3 Gs. Every civilian has a 27% chance to vote for a G and 73% chance to vote for a C.
If the Cs don't lynch a G tonight and when the Gs whack one of the Cs, there will be 7 Cs and 3 Gs. After recruiting it becomes 6vs4 and tomorrow night it could be game over.

I also think that no lynch makes sense for today. Once the Gs whack a C it's gonna be 8 vs 3 (7 vs 4 after recruiting) and it gives the Cs (and the D) at least one more day to find the Gs.

No lynch
The bodyguard will protect himself tonight no matter what.

Is it smart for him to go public? I'd have done so if I was the BG.
This would give the D a better chance to investigate a G. Not by much, I know (now the D has a 27% chance and if the BG comes out, the D will have a 30% chance).
This will likely be a short game and the Cs need to lower the Gs chance for a very quick win.
Actually, after your first post i wanted to present a similar idea. We are a small group and either it will be a very short or boring game or we can make it interesting.
I agree with BG coming out today, but i'd want then all players to confirm they've seen the message (so we are sure it's not the imposter).
Will the Gs try to pretend they are the BG? Maybe. :klin:

If there will be no other player claiming he's the BG - we can safely assume it's the real BG and there is no point in Detective wasting an investigation on him.
 

Völler

Always spot on
May 6, 2012
23,091
It depends who the BG is and how good he can play the game. Imagine it's Janna :D The BG would have played with the jailer and something would have came out.
Now it's too late, I guess, because the jailer made his move. And I don't think the Gs would have acted as the D on day 1.
They probably wouldn't have, but I don't think it would have been unwise if they had. Well, it's all "ifs" now.

his posts just seem a little off to me. Cerval is still my top choice though. I had my doubts about Mr Chocolate but he’s answered my questions well so he’s off the hook for now.
What seemed off about Osman to you?

I still think that the BG needs to come out.

And then contact me to inform him what to do :D
Yeah, this isn't it. :lol:
 

ALC

Ohaulick
Oct 28, 2010
46,526
It depends who the BG is and how good he can play the game. Imagine it's Janna :D The BG would have played with the jailer and something would have came out.
Now it's too late, I guess, because the jailer made his move. And I don't think the Gs would have acted as the D on day 1.
you know those word trend things where a word is bigger the more it appears? I’m tempted to do one with your posts because I’m sure BG would be five times as big as everything else.

What the fuck does that say?
 

campionesidd

Senior Member
Mar 16, 2013
16,789
They probably wouldn't have, but I don't think it would have been unwise if they had. Well, it's all "ifs" now.



What seemed off about Osman to you?



Yeah, this isn't it. :lol:
Mainly his idea about the no lynch. Especially since he said he doesn’t usually like it but this time he’s in favor of it.
IMO no lynch is a good strategy only for the G’s.
 

Mr Chocolate

Rubba Band Business
Dec 23, 2012
6,702
either way we go there is risk involved
if the BG reveals, at least there is an avenue for the Detective to relay info correct?
if the det investigates someone and its a G, i dont think he can relay anthing if the bodyguard is not revealed
 

Alen

Ѕenior Аdmin
Apr 2, 2007
53,907
Mainly his idea about the no lynch. Especially since he said he doesn’t usually like it but this time he’s in favor of it.
IMO no lynch is a good strategy only for the G’s.
I too seconded that. I don't like No Lynch. In this particular game, though, I think we should do it on day 1.
Nothing suspicious about what he said.

No lynch does not help the Gs tonight. If Osman is a G and he proposed no lynch, it's only because he assumed that someone else will realize it's a good play for the Cs and it will make him look like a C.
But he knows that half the fuckers who play here are neanderthals who'll find it suspicious and he wouldn't have taken that risk if he was a G.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 21)