Mafia 2018! (4 Viewers)

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
Fair enough I guess
you definitely have a better chance to convince one guy the rest of civilians can follow than convincing all civilians so strongly, that no argument can tempt them to change their vote.

unless you're a recruited G, in that case, I hope you do a Fr3sh :D
 

Monty

Tuz Royalty
May 2, 2017
2,592
you definitely have a better chance to convince one guy the rest of civilians can follow than convincing all civilians so strongly, that no argument can tempt them to change their vote.

unless you're a recruited G, in that case, I hope you do a Fr3sh :D
Can the jailer be a G?
 

Tomice

Senior Member
Mar 25, 2009
3,024
you definitely have a better chance to convince one guy the rest of civilians can follow than convincing all civilians so strongly, that no argument can tempt them to change their vote
Pretty sure I've got ALC with me, Hopefully @radekas as well since he is good enough to take the chance and do some digging of his own. I thought I had you as well but we'll get there
 

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
Can the jailer be a G?
only if Fred reassigned the jailer role yesterday evening and the Gs got lucky recruiting him during the night.

I'd be willing to bet that's not the case, last night is a strange time to recruit (why recruit after the vote not before it? why recruit during the night before you know who the main lynching suspects of tomorrow are?) and the odds are low that they got the jailer even if they decided to recruit last night.

about me jumping on Kyle yesterday - everyone kept repeating how I'm after Maddy only because I dislike the guy, so I switched to Kyle, who I believed was suspicious as well.
 

Monty

Tuz Royalty
May 2, 2017
2,592
only if Fred reassigned the jailer role yesterday evening and the Gs got lucky recruiting him during the night.

I'd be willing to bet that's not the case, last night is a strange time to recruit (why recruit after the vote not before it to influence it? why recruit during the night before you know who the main lynching suspects of tomorrow are?) and the odds are low that they got the jailer even if they decided to recruit last night.

about me jumping on Kyle yesterday - everyone kept repeating how I'm after Maddy only because I dislike the guy, so I switched to Kyle, who I believed was suspicious as well.
if the jailer exposes himself today could he not then get recruited? or was the recruiting thing only possible last night?
 

Tomice

Senior Member
Mar 25, 2009
3,024
about me jumping on Kyle yesterday - everyone kept repeating how I'm after Maddy only because I dislike the guy, so I switched to Kyle, who I believed was suspicious as well.
I also told Voller I think that one of Maddy or Kyle are sure G's but not both. Now we know Kyle was the C between them

They were both suspicious for the same reasons, mainly strongly defending Blondu without solid reason
 

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
if the jailer exposes himself today could he not then get recruited? or was the recruiting thing only possible last night?
he could get recruited, that's why he has to vote before jail time when he reveals himself, that's the vote all Cs should follow, because we're 99% sure it was cast by a C, that's the only way I can think of uniting the Cs. otherwise we're hoping from a miracle from the Lawyer.
 

Monty

Tuz Royalty
May 2, 2017
2,592
he could get recruited, that's why he has to vote before jail time when he reveals himself, that's the vote all Cs should follow, because we're 99% sure it was cast by a C.
what if you are a G and you know you have recruited the jailer and we are being lured into a trap

edit: yes i also find it strange that you wasted 2 days on a petty personal feud, got kyle killed, and suddenly you have a 'master plan'
 

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
what if you are a G and you know you have recruited the jailer and we are being lured into a trap
that's possible, but highly unlikely, as I said, the timing of recruiting and the chances for recruiting the jailer from 8 Cs make it very unlikely that jailer is recruited.

where are the other Gs supporting my idea? :D all I see is push back with shit like "what if jailer gets it wrong". either way, if one or two civilians get it wrong tonight, the game is done, it's over. other Cs will have to convince the jailer to join the right vote anyways.
 

Tomice

Senior Member
Mar 25, 2009
3,024
I'll ask the the Jailer to wait until this afternoon before doing anything. We might have a safer way to get 2-3 C's together

- - - Updated - - -

I'm off for now
 

Maddy

Oracle of Copenhagen
Jul 10, 2009
16,545
I also told Voller I think that one of Maddy or Kyle are sure G's but not both. Now we know Kyle was the C between them

They were both suspicious for the same reasons, mainly strongly defending Blondu without solid reason
Suspicious for defending blondu? Only idiots would believe blondu would SCREENSHOT his fucken inbox as a G.

@Basel93 @Klin @ALC @radekas @ADP1897 @pitbull @Monty @Wittl @Jethro @campionesidd @whomever ive forgotten

VOTE FOR ME. I dont wanna play anymore. Lawyer dont save me.
 

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
I'll ask the the Jailer to wait until this afternoon before doing anything. We might have a safer way to get 2-3 C's together

I'm off for now
what's not safe about my idea? restricting the jailer to vote on shorter time span only makes him more exposed for possible recruiting. I say the jailer should do whatever the fuck he intends to do and vote when he wants to.

- - - Updated - - -

edit: yes i also find it strange that you wasted 2 days on a petty personal feud, got kyle killed, and suddenly you have a 'master plan'
fuck you dude, I wasn't voting for Maddy because I dislike the asshole, I voted for him because I think he's either a G or a very crappy C contributing nothing worthwhile, didn't want to believe option 2. switched to Kyle precisely because people were saying that I got triggered by Maddy's asshole ways.

about my master plan - either provide a better one that beats the incredibly low odds of survival Cs have at this point or shut up. you do have to vote the same a jailer and every other civilian out there if you want to lynch a G, any better ideas on how to achieve that?
 

Wittl

Senior Member
Contributor
Feb 21, 2017
11,311
Suspicious for defending blondu? Only idiots would believe blondu would SCREENSHOT his fucken inbox as a G.

@Basel93 @Klin @ALC @radekas @ADP1897 @pitbull @Monty @Wittl @Jethro @campionesidd @whomever ive forgotten

VOTE FOR ME. I dont wanna play anymore. Lawyer dont save me.
Meltdown one :lol:

- - - Updated - - -

fuck you dude, I wasn't voting for Maddy because I dislike the asshole, I voted for him because I think he's either a G or a very crappy C contributing nothing worthwhile, didn't want to believe option 2. switched to Kyle precisely because people were saying that I got triggered by Maddy's asshole ways.

about my master plan - either provide a better one that beats the incredibly low odds of survival Cs have at this point or shut up. you do have to vote the same a jailer and every other civilian out there if you want to lynch a G, any better ideas on how to achieve that?
Meltdown two :touched:
 

Monty

Tuz Royalty
May 2, 2017
2,592
fuck you dude, I wasn't voting for Maddy because I dislike the asshole, I voted for him because I think he's either a G or a very crappy C contributing nothing worthwhile, didn't want to believe option 2. switched to Kyle precisely because people were saying that I got triggered by Maddy's asshole ways.

about my master plan - either provide a better one that beats the incredibly low odds of survival Cs have at this point or shut up. you do have to vote the same a jailer and every other civilian out there if you want to lynch a G, any better ideas on how to achieve that?
dont insult me with that language, what kind of uniting behaviour is that

whatever, i stand by what i said yesterday, both you and maddy are idiots for this game and both of you are proving it today
 

Monty

Tuz Royalty
May 2, 2017
2,592

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
I've posted 3 data points earlier today and what we need to focus on, but you clearly dont read my posts cuz why would you care
and every other C and G out there can post their 3 data points. not sure you can do math, but humor me, what are the chances that all Cs will make the same conclusion from all these data points when Gs are trying to sabotage the vote?

So far I've went for Wittl, Maddy went for Klin, Tomice went for Maddy and you went for me. At this point, all the Gs need to do is pick a civilian from these 4 and bombard him with more accusations and "data points", you're making it too easy for them.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 4)