as i said: i wasn´t even taking sides at this bonucci-thing.
if i had to, i would say the truth, as pretty much always around this forum, lies somewhere inbetween.
he isn´t great but not horrible either. overall his season could be considered solid imo.
sometimes i think it´s just what happens when you play for the current juve side. i guess even the best defender around, whoever that might be, would start playing silly passes if he was playing for us ^^.