Immigration (2 Viewers)

vitoria_Ally

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2002
7,232
#41
++ [ originally posted by River ] ++
And Stuart yes i do feel i have a right to complain about, and i do realise what my sacrifices can help them. But my sacrifices could also help british familys, british single parents, the eldery who have no where to live etc who are more hard up than most immigrants. The government could also help our own students and maybe they will fill these doctor jobs, instead of leaving students with £16000 debt when they graduate.
Agree completely with this part.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Slagathor

Bedpan racing champion
Jul 25, 2001
22,708
#42
++ [ originally posted by vitoria_Ally] ++
Wow, dont go so far. Everyone? Not at all.
++ [ originally posted by Erik ] ++
What bothers me is that Dutch autochtones will focus on the negative aspects of immigration. A group of Muslims for example demanded their religion was mentioned in the Dutch Constitution because a fairly large minority in the nation is Muslim.

The Dutch public then immediately pointed their fingers: "Those Muslims..."

Yet when most Muslims in this nation are fine with the situation as it is now, an opinion poll recently showed. Its this overgeneralisation that's the source of all problems around immigration.

Why is it that everyone's willing to accept that there are criminals when natives commit crimes yet when foreigners do it, it immediately becomes an issue of 'we should kick them all out.'? I don't get that.
;)
 

Slagathor

Bedpan racing champion
Jul 25, 2001
22,708
#44
No, I never speak on behalf of the entire world. I haven't even visited any nation outside Europe.

And I only seldomly make general statements about the Netherlands either. I usually refer to the majority though, I meant that this time again. Thought that was clear but maybe I should have used different words.
 

vitoria_Ally

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2002
7,232
#45
++ [ originally posted by Erik ] ++
No, I never speak on behalf of the entire world. I haven't even visited any nation outside Europe.

And I only seldomly make general statements about the Netherlands either. I usually refer to the majority though, I meant that this time again. Thought that was clear but maybe I should have used different words.
If that's what you think - fine for me :D
 

vitoria_Ally

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2002
7,232
#47
You dont expect me to go through all your posts now, dont you?
I will tell you that, if I notice it again ;)

But what I remeber now: you tend to use words, which means generalisations just like that: people instead of some people, all instead of some etc.
Like when we were talking about match in UEFA Cup: you used 2-3 generalisations on 1 page of talk.
 

BigIzz

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2002
1,088
#48
National boundires are a convention, they don't really exist. They are just lines on a map, political divisions. Of course there will always be cultural differences between people living far away places, but these are diminishing. The nation-state as we know it is slowly losing its power and I think someday, thanks to things like the internet, television, global telecommunication, air travel, etc. we may not have Americans and Italians and Chinese and Iraqis but we may just have people. And if it was done right wouldn't that be a wonderful world to live in? Sure it may require some out of the box thinking but just look where all of the postsers in this discussion come from. Everyone was able to wiegh in with their opinion, respond to other peoples points, etc. from all over the world, all in minutes. Such a thing would have been impossible 100 years ago, even 20 years ago. Who knows what the future holds?
 

Slagathor

Bedpan racing champion
Jul 25, 2001
22,708
#49
++ [ originally posted by vitoria_Ally ] ++
You dont expect me to go through all your posts now, dont you?
I will tell you that, if I notice it again ;)

But what I remeber now: you tend to use words, which means generalisations just like that: people instead of some people, all instead of some etc.
Like when we were talking about match in UEFA Cup: you used 2-3 generalisations on 1 page of talk.
Yes that's always been a problem of mine. I have everything in order in my mind, in perfect Dutch.

But then I have to type it and gets all messed up :D
 

gray

Senior Member
Moderator
Apr 22, 2003
30,260
#50
++ [ originally posted by BigIzz ] ++
National boundires are a convention, they don't really exist. They are just lines on a map, political divisions. Of course there will always be cultural differences between people living far away places, but these are diminishing. The nation-state as we know it is slowly losing its power and I think someday, thanks to things like the internet, television, global telecommunication, air travel, etc. we may not have Americans and Italians and Chinese and Iraqis but we may just have people. And if it was done right wouldn't that be a wonderful world to live in? Sure it may require some out of the box thinking but just look where all of the postsers in this discussion come from. Everyone was able to wiegh in with their opinion, respond to other peoples points, etc. from all over the world, all in minutes. Such a thing would have been impossible 100 years ago, even 20 years ago. Who knows what the future holds?
Sounds good, but too idealistic IMO. There's too many conservationists around for that kind of thing to happen.
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,986
#52
++ [ originally posted by River ] ++
Something that bothers me quite alot. So im posting here to hear your views/other nations views on the issue

In the Uk assylum seekers come to this country because the UK offers them better than anywere else in the world. They get here easily without problems. Which i dont have much of a problem with except i think it needs to be under control more.

But when they get here, they complain about the british government, what they are recieving for being an assylum seeker, racial indifference, lack of support etc. The government consider improving their conditions, and they demand it. When infact its already better than anywhere, and what right do they really have to demand changes to british rule and demand more of a government that isnt theres?

I dont have a problem with people coming to the country. I only have a problem with there new demands which take government money, tax payers money from other things like health care and education, british citizens lose out so we can house and accomodate for them.

Yes you might say the Uk being a wealthy country has a dutie to help these not-as fortunate people. I agree inpart, but i think if you wanna come here you have to expect a degree of difference and have to be willing to work like the rest of us. Or else dont come at all.

Some Assylum seekers do generally come here for a better life and a chance to work and earn. But most just come here to sit around on there ass doing nothing and take money for doing it.

What do you think?
We finally agree on something River. ;)

The thing that pisses me the most is when Mexicans come over the boarder to our country, and live their life like they still live in Mexico. What I mean by this is that their lifestyle remains the same; for example, they seem like they're not trying to improve their English, and expect everything to be made clear to them in their native langauge. I seen situations where Immigrants think that everybody should interact with them in their Native voices, but I got news for them: not everybody speaks Spanish or Arabic or whatever. They get angry when nothing is done for them, and take it out in other actions. How are we able to help them if they don't understand how things work around here. All I ever see Mexicans doing around here is making people scared at the local mall, sitting outside of comercial stores like 7-11, and getting a hot temper when nothing goes their way. They should learn how to speak a little English first, then get a job and go on from there.
 

BigIzz

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2002
1,088
#54
There is this Pizza place in my town that I often go to. It's owned by this older Italian guy and his daughter. They have a number of Mexican employees who work there. Now when the old Italian guy is there, the Pizzeria runs horribly. He yells at kids, has a hard time keeping track of who pays and who doesn't. He is always confused, screwing up orders, the kitchen looks like it is a mad house. His daughter is just mean and treats the customers very poorly and doesn't show any respect for someone like me who has been there hundreds of times before. She thinks I would do something like walk out with paying, and really creates a hassle. Now when the owners aren't there, the Mexican guys run the place like clockwork. They are always very friendly, on top of things, treat the customers well. It brings such a smile to my face when I walk in there and don't see either the owner or his daughter because I know I am going to have a plesant dining expierence.

Now this is just an anecdote and both the Mexicans and the old Italian guys are probably immigrants, but most pople would say the Italian guy was American before the Mexicans. They may be here illegally, they may not speak the best English (although neither does the old Italian guy), they are almost certianly forced to work long hours, probably aren't very well educated (at least here in the US), get paid poorly and under the table. It just always amazes me they are able to run the pizzeria so much better then the owner. If only the old guy would stay home, the place would be so much better.

Around here, Mexicans line up at the train station as day laborers. They get picked up by contractors or whoever, get paid like $100 to do some meinal job. They have to work all day, don't have any insurance or anything like that. But they are just trying to work hard and provide for their family. They want their kids to have an easier time then they did. And to be honest, someone in society needs to fill those sort of jobs. And if its immigrants who are willing to do whatever just to get a foot in the door, then good for them. There isn't any shame at all in that. And yes, some of them don't try to assimilate or anything, don't learn the language, live off welfare and unemployment or whatever. However I know a lot of "real Americans" that do that too, if not moreso.
 

SilvLightning

Senior Member
Sep 1, 2002
1,217
#55
Thank you for that great post BigIzz. You truly know that not all mexicans are the same like many people assume.

++ [ originally posted by Torkel ] ++
This was a quality post, BigIzz.

That depends, when do you stop being a guest? When you get your green card? When you're granted political asylum? When you become a citizen? Never?

What's you view on this?
Imo never. People will always see you as a guest just because you weren't born here or because you are from a different culture. My whole family is legal in this country and we have been living here for many years. We are all citizens now, yet everyone assumes that just because we are Mexicans we must be illegal.:rolleyes:
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,986
#56
++ [ originally posted by SilvLightning ] ++
:rolleyes:umm, Andy...not all of us Mexicans are like that you know.
I don't know but from various posts that you have made you seem to really just hate us....
Nah man, I don't hate you at all. I hate those who live around where I do, making people's lives miserable. A Mexican guy recently raped a mother, and had no remorse for it. Mexican gangs are on the rise, increasing violence around here as well. I don't like those people.
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,986
#57
++ [ originally posted by SilvLightning ] ++
:rolleyes:umm, Andy...not all of us Mexicans are like that you know.
I don't know but from various posts that you have made you seem to really just hate us....
And by the way, where are those other posts you say I have. That was my first post that has anything to do with this topic.
 

SilvLightning

Senior Member
Sep 1, 2002
1,217
#58
++ [ originally posted by Andy ] ++


Nah man, I don't hate you at all. I hate those who live around where I do, making people's lives miserable. A Mexican guy recently raped a mother, and had no remorse for it. Mexican gangs are on the rise, increasing violence around here as well. I don't like those people.
Well Andy, I trully understand why you are angry with those mexicans. To tell you the truth I also hate people like them that are only here to increase violence in our communities.

Regarding your previous post....I remember that you once said that you saw a game between the US and Mexico and the mexicans were yelling 'Osama', and that because of that you have lost respect to mexicans. Maybe I'm just jumping into conclusions or something but these sort of posts make me assume that you hate Mexicans in general. Even though I agree with you that what they yelled was very wrong, but again we are not all like that.

++ [ originally posted by Andy ] ++

I will never vote for anyone from Mexico, even if she has that back. For all I know she was in the stands in Mexico City for that game against the U-21's of Mexico and the U.S., where a Olympic spot was fought for. It must of been hard for our boys with those mexicans cheering "Osama Osama" during the match and during OUR NATIONAL ANTHEM. I have no respect for them at all now.
 

Roverbhoy

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2002
1,840
#59
Difficult subject for discussion...but so far going along nicely.

For the recored Scotland is actually trying to recruit any and all imigrants due to a population decline (irrespective of qualifications)

What gets me though is the xenophobic tv and radio programmes we get in the UK blaming immigrants for everything from almost all crime, to the increase in the defecit in the balance of payments.

You get Joe Bloggs from Hackney phoning in saying the country's going to the dogs, and he's had enough, and he's going to leave Britain, and go to Australia or Canada to live...with no job...no money...blah, blah, blah. (see the irony folks!)

Can I ask the question...where do we get the idea that the UK offers the best financial package? What are these figures and their sources? Seen it used by the right wingers in the media, but no one has actually put up.
The same people who say that England subsidises Scotland, but only decide to use those stats that suit their claims while ignoring others which completly smash their argument to pieces...but those stats never reach the media in England for some reason, so the masses down there think it's all true.

We had stories circulated that imigrants were getting grants of ten thousand pounds for cars so that they could go job hunting whilst Brits had to walk, jumping queues for the best public housing, payed to take taxis to and from the benfit centre, jumping the queue for medical treatment, and so on ...all proved complete nonsense, but now ingrained in psyche of the public.

True that Britain, as a small country, can only take so many immigrants before we start to sink into the Atlantic, but we should ask the question first why we don't have enough doctors, engineers, etc, of our own before we go blaming people who mostly are here to improve themselves and contribute. Those who are here to scrounge usually get found out eventually and shown the door, these are the small minority. Lets give the rest a helping hand up...for the sake of the UK

I'm sure the above also goes for each and every other country too
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,986
#60
++ [ originally posted by SilvLightning ] ++

Well Andy, I trully understand why you are angry with those mexicans. To tell you the truth I also hate people like them that are only here to increase violence in our communities.

Regarding your previous post....I remember that you once said that you saw a game between the US and Mexico and the mexicans were yelling 'Osama', and that because of that you have lost respect to mexicans. Maybe I'm just jumping into conclusions or something but these sort of posts make me assume that you hate Mexicans in general. Even though I agree with you that what they yelled was very wrong, but again we are not all like that.
Yeah, I guess I forgot about that post. When I posted that about the game, I was obviously very angry and I showed my hate towards them. Its just natural to do so. But you got to admit, what they did was rather disturbing, and you can see why I would give some rather angry opinions.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 2)