Ok with all due respect to Scirea, he would've never won all those trophies if not for Platini, on the other hand we wouldn't have won most of our trophies since 1995 if not for Del Piero.
Buy on AliExpress.com
Il Capitano Alessandro Del Piero (56 Viewers)
- Thread starter Chxta
- Start date
Buy on AliExpress.com
No way. Scirea was at juventus from '74 to '88, while Platini only played for juventus from '82 till '87. By the time Platini joined, Scirea had already won numerous honours, including a world championship.
edit:
Freakin' Beckenbauer was still a step behind Scirea.
I'm not sure DP should be placed ahead of Tardelli either, by the way.
edit:
Freakin' Beckenbauer was still a step behind Scirea.
I'm not sure DP should be placed ahead of Tardelli either, by the way.
Well, there was a certain Bettega and stuff.
Comon if two players are close in the competiton for the greatest player status, the forward is meant to get the edge.
PS and just statistically DP's era is just the most successful in our history, for a fact.
Anyway, this can go on forever... Don, just remember we're not talking about the skill, we're talking about the contribution to Juventus. And DP certainly has done more than the rest, I actually think you're the only one to argue about that...
Comon if two players are close in the competiton for the greatest player status, the forward is meant to get the edge.
PS and just statistically DP's era is just the most successful in our history, for a fact.
Anyway, this can go on forever... Don, just remember we're not talking about the skill, we're talking about the contribution to Juventus. And DP certainly has done more than the rest, I actually think you're the only one to argue about that...
.
@Rab
Thereabouts, slightly more perhaps.
You're trying to discredit my opinion, by pointing out i've seen little of him. I've rarely been convinced of a player's ability like his though.
I'm fine with you guys preffering DP as the best, but i'm offering a little historical perspective to your bold claim of DP being the all-time greatest. Juventus is great for a reason, it's quite something to call Del Piero the best, when the club has such a rich history.
Thereabouts, slightly more perhaps.
You're trying to discredit my opinion, by pointing out i've seen little of him. I've rarely been convinced of a player's ability like his though.
I'm fine with you guys preffering DP as the best, but i'm offering a little historical perspective to your bold claim of DP being the all-time greatest. Juventus is great for a reason, it's quite something to call Del Piero the best, when the club has such a rich history.
Of course the club has such a history and we're not talking about any players here to discredit your opinion. History, Goals, loyality, tough moments, class we've seen all this in Del Piero.
But what have you seen in Scirea to be sure that he's even greater than Del Piero? 8 matches isn't enough to discredit someone like Del Piero.
You haven't seen ONE single season Scirea playing. Leave alone Del Piero, you can't even say he's better than Maldini or Baresi just because you've watched some of the highlights and he's the most capped Juve player so far.
Anyway, this can go on forever
But what have you seen in Scirea to be sure that he's even greater than Del Piero? 8 matches isn't enough to discredit someone like Del Piero.
You haven't seen ONE single season Scirea playing. Leave alone Del Piero, you can't even say he's better than Maldini or Baresi just because you've watched some of the highlights and he's the most capped Juve player so far.
Anyway, this can go on forever
