If you had to pick only one... (7 Viewers)

Club or NT?

  • Club(Juventus...)

  • National Team


Results are only viewable after voting.

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,916
Ultras? You're seriously referring to ultras? You think ultras are nationalists?
Well, perhaps they're not nationalists, but they don't seem to be very accepting of foreigners.

But no matter their political affiliations, they do cause problems in stadiums, which is the real issue here. So to blast the international game while supporting club football despite having the same problems in both is nonsensical.
 

Ford Prefect

Senior Member
May 28, 2009
10,557
The problem is, this stuff happens everywhere. Not only in international football, but also club football, city gangs, people who have the same name as you, and people the same age as you in your city. It's not just international football.

That's why I find blasting international football while loving club football is a joke. Then add on cheering for a country known for it's extreme nationalism and you simply are not making any sense whatsoever.
What you've done here is made me out to be a hypocrite, Club football is different (as i said) Club football isnt on a national level and should be dealt with on a regional level.

I DO NOT SUPPORT PATRIOTISM OR NATIONALISM. (as i said)

BUT

It exists (as i said)

and

because it exists. (as i said)

I do not want people to associate the people that live in england or for that matter any country with those that go and behave like idiots in support of a country in international sports. (as i said) Ill make it clear, I dont want that to happen, i dont support it happening, but it does happen and whilst it does happen i have to compromise, are you still confused?
 

Martin

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2000
56,913
There is absolutely nothing wrong with patriotism in sports.
Patriotism is a short walk away from nationalism, and sports doubtlessly ignites nationalism.

Basically, as long as we're all the same there is no pretext for hostility. But as soon as you draw a line, creating an "us" and a "them" you are paving the way for tribalism. Patriotism is relatively absurd. I'm going to support the people that happen to live in the country that I live in, for no real reason. Knowing full well that if I happened to live in a different country I'd support the people over there. So it's nothing to do with the people really, it's basically a Pavlovian reflex.
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,315
Well, perhaps they're not nationalists, but they don't seem to be very accepting of foreigners.

But no matter their political affiliations, they do cause problems in stadiums, which is the real issue here. So to blast the international game while supporting club football despite having the same problems in both is nonsensical.
I'm going to give you three words:

campanilismo - risorgimento - terrone

You can do this, Andy. You can learn some of the basics of Italy. You can understand something about this country. It is possible, I have faith in you.
 

swag

L'autista
Administrator
Sep 23, 2003
84,749
Allegiances to club or country really don't make a difference to me. There are idiot supporters, period. And those people, by association with the flag of their country or the jersey of their favorite club player, give others a bad name by association.

Nationality is just one dimension. Clubism (even if it isn't a word) is largely just a different dimension on that when it comes to footie fans and hooliganism. (I think it was a style of painting once attempted by Picasso until he settled on Cubism.)
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
115,916
What you've done here is made me out to be a hypocrite, Club football is different (as i said) Club football isnt on a national level and should be dealt with on a regional level.

I DO NOT SUPPORT PATRIOTISM OR NATIONALISM. (as i said)

BUT

It exists (as i said)

and

because it exists. (as i said)

I do not want people to associate the people that live in england or for that matter any country with those that go and behave like idiots in support of a country in international sports. (as i said) Ill make it clear, I dont want that to happen, i dont support it happening, but it does happen and whilst it does happen i have to compromise, are you still confused?
I can't help but think you're trying to spur on those stereotypes, though.
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,315
That is a great phrase, though.
It's catchy too. But my point is: no one who has ever been to Italy would call Italians nationalists. Hell, they'd be better off if they were nationalists. Andy's confused and mixing up several phenomena.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 7)