are you serious? I find Heinze quite well attacking judging from his performance 2 seasons ago for Man Utd since last season he didn't play much. Basically I agree on the anticipation part but you gotta admit Chielini tackles better. Italian style of course. Heinze is basically natural playing as a wing back but Chielini is faster and his sliding tackles remind me of Cannavaro. With a pinch of dirty playing involved. Basically you need these qualities to play in Serie A.
What Andy said I wont agree totally though I'm not quite sure whether I'm biased in the sense that I've always remained hopeful Chielini is our Zambro replacement. I'm pretty sure you guys agree that although IF Chielini is worse than Heinze, he ain't that far away. And Juve wouldn't have much problems with that. And Gazzo, I'd like to see that happening. Molinaro on the left and Chielini as CB. As long as they are both playing. Hopefully some chances for Criscito as well but I doubt so. I think Boumsong will be partnering Andrade
All I care about is that we should get rid of one centerback if we are to get Heinze. As long as we are keeping Chielini. Heinze wouldnt be all that bad an addition. And actually Grygera plays quite well as a CB too if you guys have seen him play as one before