We could have some very long discussions then.. My best mate is a personal trainer and I've been involved with that kind of knowledge when I worked part time in a supplment store through Uni.. Just one simple question, do you think it's possible to gain muscle (not maintain) and lose body fat simutaneously? Ofcourse the answer is very long and difficult but being the proffessional that you are I'd like to know your opinion (I'm not being a smartass).. IMO when ever I've personally tried to focus on both at the same time Ive always come up short in one of the two areas (usually building muscle) but sometimes the other way around.. My reasoning is that it is simply impossible to build quality muscle whilst losing fat no matter what any literature says for the simple fact that your body has to be in a negative state of calories to burn fat and thus in building muscle your body must be in a positive state of calories and that theres no two ways about this.. He thinks it's possible but I disagree, IMO from all I've read and expirementated you can only maintain muscle not significantly build it.. Thus the cutting period is needed which doesn't take too long thankfully and it's neccessary to 95% of the people I know
This is the million pound question, If you ever find a 100% concrete answer to that please let me know!! It's the most asked question i get. The thing to consider again, is that people are different and what works for someone may not always work for another person. For some people creatine works wonders, for others it's about as useful as eating mud. There has been so much written on this topic and there are so many contrasting ideas, some people say you can, others swear you cant, i remember not long ago two of my colleagues arguing about it,
I have found personally that generally, it's not possible to gain much muscle whilst losing fat, the main thing to consider is efficiency,
If we take a 4 month period, a persons goal is, lose fat and build muscle, it's much more efficient to follow a mass building programme for a 2-3 months and then follow up with a period of cutting in which you maintain the muscle you have built as opposed to a 4 month period of trying to do both.
It is possible to build muscle while keeping body fat low, maintaining muscle is not hard, but u already stated that of course!
So basically, i would agree completely with what you've said, to build QUALITY muscle, and a decent amount at that, whilst losing fat, it's pretty damn hard simply for the fact that they CONTRADICT each other. To Build muscle you need more calories i.e. over you normal calorie intake, to lose fat you need to be under your normal colorie intake, i.e. burn more calories
Many boxers are able to build quality muscle due to thier rigourous training schedules, as well as footballers, and rugby players, so building muscle whilst staying lean is very possible, just losing fat AND gaining a decent amount of muscle is tough
You also have to consider the level and fintess of the person, for beginers, in the first few months of their training they may lose fat and gain some muscle before especially if they have never done weights before and get some decent nutrition, but for people who have been doing it for years, it's very inadvisable, not impossible, but inadvisable, it's not the efficient way to do it
It is possible to increase strength whilst losing fat, and i've read papers stating that an increase in strength in theory leads to an increase in muscle, even though it may be small, an increase none the less
As well as this, when doing the mass part, i find people think, oh well, im building, so i can eat crap and i don't have to do any cardio whatsoever, which isn't the case as the heart weakens which makes bloodflow around the body inefficient, bloodflow is very important as well as the condition of the heart, and it also means while the person may put on msucle, they'll put on a lot of fat as well (only making the fat loss cutting stage harder for themselves)
bottom line, you're right
