Agree with everything. Let me piggyback this idea:
People love to make excuses when we lose because we are too proud to just accept defeat. If we just look at the way the team has performed in the three games, results aside, we look poor in the exact same places we thought we would be coming into the transfer period. Salihamidzic was a good pickup, because he is a versatile backup. Grygera was good because he is a better RB than Zebina and could fill a void at CB if needed. Tiago and Almiron are both good players, but I questioned why we needed both of them. Iaquinta is a good backup and that is it.
Basically. This team has 5 players. DP, Nedved, Camo, Trez and Buffon. Everybody else is just trying to fit in here. That is not good. That means that Ranieri has not done his job. He has had plenty of time to pick a formation and mold the players into his style. The problem is... he hasn't molded anything. He is confused and IMO he is making horrible lineup descisions.
Grygera is our best RB. He is a very good RB. He is an average CB. WHY is he playing CB??? I would rather start Chiellini, Criscito, or even Boumsong just to get this guy out at RB. He is NOT a good CB, and not nearly as effective at CB as he is at RB. Zebina is a backup at best. The guy's best season was in Serie B and so many forgot how much he actually stinks. STOP starting him because he says nice things about the club.
I have faith in Molinaro. He did good things for Siena last year. Chiellini is a better LB IMO, but his potential at LB is, IMO maxed out. I would love to see Chiellini play as a CB next to Andrade. Chiellini is powerful, combative and great in the air. He would compliment Andrade perfectly. Criscito is NOT an LB. I don't want to see another good CB prospect thrown out to the wing prematurely. He has so much potential inside, it would be a shame to waste it.
Tiago and Almiron.... both good players. Both similar players, yes Andy, they are similar in respect to what they offer us, or don't offer us I guess. That is good defence. We NEED a destroyer out there badly. With this awful defense, and Ranieri's lack of defensive prowess, we need someone to help out. We have a very good strike force with Trez, DP, Nedved and Camo. We don't need to throw more attackers out there. It is overkill. Especially if we have Almiron or Tiago supporting them. It is pointless and a waste. Nocerino has been playing very well. He is skilled for a DM and doesn't just have cement boots. PLEASE play either him, or the experienced Zanetti in front of our very average defense.
A trident attack is cute, and a couple versions of it will work. Whether we use it or not, we need to settle on a starting 11. I think that this roster has a clear and undeniable gap between 11 starters and 12 backups. I don't think there is any question who can play where and whom should be starting over whom. Ranieri is clearly uncertain and clearly did not do his homework like he should have. We aren't a deep team. It shouldn't be this hard to send 11 of our best players out there.
New Castle, Hamburg, Sunderland. I am well aware of where we have come from and what the clubs situation is. But there is NO excuse for the poor performances we have put out in each of these games. We can miss the net all we want, but we should NEVER have let half of these goals in. I see a philosophical problem with Ranieri's tactics and our roster. I am very concerned as we approach the season that we are NOT going to be performing as well as we should be. What blind faith must I have in order to make me not think Ranieri is an idiot? I do not see any logic in his formation picking and his lineups. NONE. We have learned little about our new players and like Ranieri, I have no idea how we are going to lineup. I am pretty sure he is changing the identity of the club by going to an attacking format, but I really think it will hurt us more than it will help us.
I liked DD. I liked Capello. I loved Lippi. But, I can honestly say that the hiring of Ranieri is not something I can get behind. He scares me, he is making poor decisions and our team is severely underachieving. The worst part is... he is making excuses and playing it down. They may be old, but we still have DP and Nedved, we still have Camo and Trezeguet and we still have Buffon. We need to cover up our weakness and rely on our great players. Right now, we are just over-emphasising our strength and letting our weakness out there for everyone to see. We are lucky Buffon is as good as he is, because if we had any other keeper, we would have had it much worse.
I am VERY concerned about 2007-2008. This is a very important year.