But he's not even good holding up the ball. Doesn't even do his own job.
Did you even watch Juventus last season? I don't think you did, because if so, you would have said Amauri can shoot, he can dribble (not with finesse, just with power, same as Pigface Rooney), and most importantly HE DOES cause trouble for the defense because of his presence and power, drawing defenders away with him, opening space by holding up the ball. He STILL holds up the ball well today, but isn't in the same form as he was the first half of last season.
So no, your post is blatantly wrong regarding Amauri's career, and this is not a contest between Amauri and Rooney because the latter is certainly better, but still not world class. I suggest you re-read the justified praise Amauri received last year, google target man in football, google class is permanent form is temporary, and lay off the Premiership ecstasy.