I'm not writing him off, but tonight he was just terrible, there's no getting around that. "Should've had 2 goals" my ass. He received two perfect crosses and made a meal of both. And several of his touches resulted in Catania counterattacks. As a fan, one is entitled to be critical of that.
I'm hoping he'll come good, and I haven't written him off yet. But it has to be allowed to criticize.