++ [ originally posted by Eop05 ] ++
He was always an above average right winger, but ever since he's moved to left fullback he's won a scudetto and went to a CL Final. Then the following season he was named to the Serie A team of the year. He's clearly excelled in this position more than he ever has at the right midfield position.
Bottom line is that he was never amongst the elite right midfielders. But for the past 2 seasons he's been compared to Roberto Carlos at left fullback meaning he's top 3 left fullback (terzino sinistro) in the world.
No offence, but those achievements mean little to me in terms of what they say about a player's performance. Philip Neville has won 1 Youth FA Cup, 6 English Championships, 2 FA Cups, 3 Charity shields, 1 Intercontinental Cup and 1 Champions League. That hardly means that he's the best player in his position, it just means that the team's performed around him. Juventus didn't win scudetti for a couple of seasons, and just because we won in the same season that Zambro was converted to a LB, doesn't mean that that's his best position.
I never disagreed that he's a bloody excellent left-back, in fact I think he's one of the best in the world in that position, but I'm simply saying that I think he'd be more effective if we took the burden of the defensive duties off him, and let him terrorise opposition defenders more frequently.
The only reason Zambro lost his right midfield role is because he was out for months after having surgery, and in that time Camoranesi performed excellently on the right wing. When Zambro came back, he was forced to play as a left-back, and being the Mr. Versatile that he is, he naturally excelled there. Again, that doesn't mean that his most effective position is at LB
As for being compared with Roberto Carlos, that's exactly my point. I don't want a Roberto Carlos style player to occupy our left-back position, because we all know what happens when he gets caught out and does silly things in defence. I'd rather have a decent left-back who can defend well, and switch Zambro to right midfield where he can use his Roberto Carlos-like attacking abilities to their maximum potential