First of all, nobody's going to listen to Preet, and she's not stupid either. And if it's personal, why would I whack him? I like Zach, plus I want the game to be fun.
There is no great thinking that usually goes behind whacking someone on the first day.
On the G teams I've been on, inculding yours, we normally go for the inconspicuous posters who aren't going to get themselves lynched. Players like you, Hoori, Osman are normally avoided because you tend to be protected by the jailer and bodyguard, who would consider you assets to the Cs (which odds are, you are one of).
You're being silly. Or maybe this is the justification you prepared when whacking Zach. But it's not a sound prosecution, son.
I wasn't here all day, including the whack. So even if I'm a G, the whacking order was sent without my knowledge.
I'm simply trying to find a justification behind their choice. Yes, I'd do that as a mindfuck, but I wasn't here since yesterday and my first log in today was long after the whack. That leads me into thinking who else might do that as a mindfuck? The answer I came with is - Noone.
Osman, Hoori, Deneb and Kate won't do that for sure. I'm 100% positive about this. There are players, including yourself, who'd have whacked Zach for fun, but players like you would first try to eliminate me, because you see me as a danger. You won't whack Zach if I am also a choice.
So who'd whack Zach ahead of me or Osman? Someone who doesn't even know me or Osman in a mafia game. Also, someone who dislikes Zach.
Preet is my only answer. The problem I have, though, is how did she convince the other Gs? Osman wouldn't have allowed it. Tomice, Kyle, Hoori, Ze, Soren... they wouldn't have let Preet have the whacking choice if the choice is Zach.