Gianluigi BUFFON: has to take the blame (or at least a lot of it) for the first goal. Couldn't do anything about the second. Made a couple routine saves and that was that. 5
Stephan LICHTSTEINER: ran his ass off as usual and his determination is fantastic but his final ball let us down time and time again. Needs to improve his quality in the final third, especially as this formation allowed us to get numbers into the box. 5.5
Leonardo BONUCCI: solid at the back and comfortable on the ball. He wasn't really exposed on the counter as I feared he might be. 6
Giorgio CHIELLINI: lacked assurance at times but I thought he handled Mitroglu well. 6
Kwadwo ASAMOAH: similar to Licht. Great runner and athlete but his crossing was absolutely pathetic. So many times we got our full backs right up the flank and had about 4 players in the box and the deliveries to them were piss poor. One good assist in the first half, that's not enough. 5.5
Andrea PIRLO: thank god we had him to show our full backs how to deliver a cross for the 2-2 goal. Spectacular free kick and an all around brilliant performance. Passed the ball superbly and even won the ball back a few times. MotM. 8
Claudio MARCHISIO: probably the team's most in form player right now and he produced another good showing. Good passing, energy and tactical responsibility in midfield. Should've scored in the first half though. 6.5
Paul POGBA: scored the winner, set up Pirlo's free kick with a fantastic driving run, and was a positive presence throughout. #Pogboom 7.5
Arturo VIDAL: I'm in the minority here but I thought he had a good game and looked much more like this usual self than he has this season. He offered a lot defensively and with his pressing. In fact it was him winning the ball back that allowed us to score the 1st and 3rd goals. Clearly lacking in confidence as seen when Tevez set him up and he didn't shoot, but overall I was happy with his contribution. Hopefully the penalty miss doesn't fuck us. 6
Carlos TEVEZ: poor first half, much better second half. We need more from him. 6
Alvaro MORATA: used his pace to good effect at times in the first half like when he turned his marker on half way and sprinted away from him. Missed a huge chance but honestly he was better than Tevez in the first half. 5.5
Fernando LLORENTE: changed the game. Deserves to be credited with the equaliser. Held up the ball brilliantly, set up Pogba's goal, and was generally a massive threat. Their centre backs just couldn't deal with him. 7
Max ALLEGRI: changed the formation which we all wanted and made good substitutions. I especially liked how we still went forward at 3-2 up instead of sitting back. Can't ask for much more. 7.5