I really cant believe anyone can call Tevez prolific, ridicolous. The dude has 5 league goals this season (Vidic scored more), and he has started around 17 games, no excuses.
I think that you have missed the point, we only mean a better goal scorer than Cassano, no one claimed that Tevez is a finisher...
Only the bolded is where Tevez is better.
I don't know what do you mean by form and i don't get what do you mean by experience.
Concentration- i guess you mean Cassano's outbursts from the past, so ok, i'll give you that too.
But Tevez certainly isn't a better goalscorer (they both aren't Trez like forwards) and definitely isn't a better dribbler or has better ball control.
Tevez is much more of a hard worker (we have Amauri and Iaquinta to do that job), but Cassano is more creative and bigger talent than Tevez (we have Del Piero).
Tevez isn't good enough to replace a goalscorer like Trez and isn't technically as great as a player like Del Piero. Tevez is very useful but in our team he can replace Amauri or Iaquinta.
Cassano on the other hand would be a replacement for Del Piero.
Atm we don't really need them (although they are both players that no team would say NO to) but in the near future a player like Cassano will be much more needed in Juve than a player like Tevez.
I have reasons to believe that Tevez is in a better physical form, mostly because Cassano has skipped for too many training sessions.
Yes Cassano is very unstable as a character and thats the first year he has been proved somewhat consistent as a player...
I think that Cassano's dribbling skills has been overrated, even by the time he has been playing in Rome. I just dont like his Totti whining style and i dont rate it either.
I dont believe that he has what it takes to be as efficient as Tevez has been proved to be in EPL, against the highest competition. I think that Tevez has more speed, power and determination and he can provide with better penetrations because of that. Impressive flicks in slow mo are not as effective IMHO.
And again i dont mean this season, i hate one season revelations, because they have tendency to disappear soon after that.
A valuable player like Tevez has great potential and a bad season or two cannot erase that... Cassano is also talented but i was impressed by Tevez performance in Manure at the 1st season, more than Cassano's in Real.
And i also rate hit NT team performances even higher.
I havent seen his work in the Argentine championship, but i have seen Cassano's in Italy and as far as i remember, Cassano never scored like 30/season, unlike Tevez...
Tevez is not a goalscorer and cant be used as a targetman, he is a SS, just like Cassano.
But he is far more useful as goalscorer and targetman than Cassano, if the tactical need asks him to be and IMO, at least as efficient, if not better, as Cassano is at his SS duties. Thats why i believe that he is overall a better forward.
And considering that Amauri, Diego, Camo, Giovinco and Camo can create,
i think that the most important factor is goalscoring.
This superiority of Tevez, comparing to Cassano, is decisive for me atm, considering our current needs.
PErsonally, i repeat i wouldnt sign any of them right now...