I think Carlo is a good coach to Organize a team's tactics.
Juve looked very Solid in Many games when he was coach. Juve's style didn't depend on work-your-ass-off as this team does.
Carlo did a good job in re-ogganizing juve once lippi left in the end of the 98-99 season when juve was defending champs but at mid-table.
The problem with ancelotti: in every 10 games, he has to screw-up big time once. and that "once" is usually either the MOST important game, or the Least important game.
Examples,
Juve Lost to Lazio 4-1 in the 00-01 season when juve, lazio and Roma were well in the hunt for the scudetto.
Same year, Roma tied juve 2-2.
Celta Vigo 4-0 Juve!
The Hamberg and Panathainakos games in the CL!
(juve should have beat these easy teams)
Also against the weaker teams:
Perugia 1-0 juve (cost us the scudetto)
Atalanta 2-1 Juve.
There is a pattern of bad results with Carlo, They are mostly in the decisive games and not just the tough ones.so this makes me think that he isn't a good motivator.
.....
With Lippi, our loss patterns seem to come from other reasons: Like lack of options and fatige. (Excpet for the ManU game #2 :fero)
..........................
anyway, Scudetto runner-ups two years in a row isn't too bad!
but i'm glad he seems to be doing better with Milan this season.
If there's any team, other than juve, that i would want to win the CL or serie A, then it's Milan
Forza Carlo