The reason Vidal made my top 10 list is because 1) it was only based on players I've seen play during the years I've been a fan and 2) a lot of spaces opened up in 2006 (players such as Thuram and Zambrotta for instance, won't even be in my top 100 for what they said). Players like Cannavaro and Ibra will not be considered either, for pure douchebaggery.
Vidal wouldn't have made an all time historical list, as I would've included Charles, Sivori, Boniperti, Platini and the likes.
Del Piero
Nedved
Trezeguet
Buffon
Zidane
Marchisio
Davids
Pirlo
Chiellini
Vidal
Players who were very close to making the list: Iuliano, Conte, Ferrara, Deschamps, Montero, Vialli, Tacchinardi.
Honorable mentions: Pessotto, Birindelli, Camoranesi, Lichtsteiner, Barzagli.
Notable absentees: Baggio. I do remember the 94 World Cup fondly, but I didn't become a die hard juventino until 1996, and hence, il divino codino is not of my era.