I prefer the 2010-11 edition post Quagliarella injury.
Storari
Motta-Bonucci-Chiellini-De Ceglie/Grosso
Krasic-Melo-Aquilani-Marchisio
Toni-Amauri
We actually used that against Napoli and got trashed by a Cavani hat trick at the San Paolo
I think that has to be the worst Juve starting eleven I've witnessed. I also can't believe that this was only 3 years ago. Conte and Marotta really turned this team around.