Andrea Pirlo (60 Viewers)

[Fr3sh]

It's been decided thst he's not a Juve legend when he left. What has changed between thst time and his retirement? Nothing. Keep in history even though was beautiful history.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[DAiDEViL]

It's been decided thst he's not a Juve legend when he left. What has changed between thst time and his retirement? Nothing. Keep in history even though was beautiful history.

A chance to revoke a wrong decision

 

[pitbull]

The bonucci case was done only with the caveat it will not be used retroactively on past players.

You making it sound like the mortal people were begging for this and almighty mod team went "ok, this one time, but thats it". I think its a decent approach, I remember there was also a vote involved with the 50 stars process

 

[JCK]

Why not? We did it with Bonucci, this is highly similar.

Because of the fear of Zidane being a legend.

 

[campionesidd]

Because of the fear of Zidane being a legend.

If he manages us and wins the CL, he will deserve it.

 

[JCK]

If he manages us and wins the CL, he will deserve it.

As things stand even after beating us in the CL final recently, whether you (and a few others) like it or not, Zidane is a Juventus legend. He is considered a legend by the club, the current management, the previous management, the management that sold him to Real and millions of fans. It's only those who don't like him for some silly reason who say otherwise. Alas a few moderators are of that opinion.

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

I feel so privileged to watch this man play live for us, an absolute joy to watch - pure artistry on the football field. Will go down as one of the greatest midfielders of any generation. A Juventus legend too, in my eyes. Grazie per tutto, Andrea!

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

Vidal and Pirlo should be in the legends section.

Pirlo definitely.

 

[lgorTudor]

If he manages us and wins the CL, he will deserve it.

This. I adore Zidane as player but calling him a Juventus legend is not only a way to belittle our club but also to devaluate real Juventus legends like Platini, Gigi, ADP etc.

Pirlo is closer to that status but still misses it by a country mile

 

[X Æ A-12]

Most important juventus signing of the 21st century (barring buffon) by far. Legend for sure

Ok at least most important post calciopoli

 

[zizinho]

Most important juventus signing of the 21st century (barring buffon) by far. Legend for sure

the question is, was he the most important signing in whole of Serie A for that period? imo its a close one between him and Bonuccis move to Milan

 

[GordoDeCentral]

You making it sound like the mortal people were begging for this and almighty mod team went "ok, this one time, but thats it". I think its a decent approach, I remember there was also a vote involved with the 50 stars process

Nice psychological tool there, however if that was the case i wouldn't have repled to your question

 

[pitbull]

Nice psychological tool there, however if that was the case i wouldn't have repled to your question

I maybe said it like a joke, but I honestly dont believe it should be something that is handled by the mod team. The poll creation rights and thread editing rights imo are there for you to make sure that the forum is tidy and pleasent to visit, not to make decisions like who is a Juve legend and who's not. Because in that case it makes little sense to have Liverpool, Aberdeen or Bayern fans with mod rights, Id trust Badass more than them when it comes to Juve related decisions

 

[campionesidd]

Most important juventus signing of the 21st century (barring buffon) by far. Legend for sure

Ok at least most important post calciopoli

Most important would be Chiellini for me.

 

[X Æ A-12]

Most important would be Chiellini for me.

He was not post calciopoli signing tho

 

[Ventus]

Legend for sure. Also for many people outside of Italy, Pirlo hit stardom to the casual football fan while playing for Juventus. For many people in England, they think of Juve when they remember Pirlo. Pirlo was overshadowed in the press by the likes of Kaka, Shechenko etc. while at AC Milan.

 

[.zero]

He was not post calciopoli signing tho

 

[Fr3sh]

Would impregnate

 

[lgorTudor]

VJ One of the few untouched by Dan 'Hold her tighter' Schneider

 

[GordoDeCentral]

I maybe said it like a joke, but I honestly dont believe it should be something that is handled by the mod team. The poll creation rights and thread editing rights imo are there for you to make sure that the forum is tidy and pleasent to visit, not to make decisions like who is a Juve legend and who's not. Because in that case it makes little sense to have Liverpool, Aberdeen or Bayern fans with mod rights, Id trust Badass more than them when it comes to Juve related decisions

The non juve mod input is at 8%, so your point is moot. A juve legend has to be so undisputedly, if there's contention they cease to be so. We just uphold this mantra which cannot be challenged by a 51%.