IMO a "fanboy", is a person that blindly defends his favourite player even when he knows he is wrong,, or even convinces himself that he is not wrong.
While i dont consider myself a quag fanboy, i think i can answer ur question. If it means a striker who is better than him, the answer is simple!! ........why not?.
If that will bring sucess to us, lets do it!.
I would prefer to keep him if we fail to sign jovetic, or use him to get higuain. But i would rather sacrifice matri and giovinco in any case... before quags. I beleive that he was our most effective striker given the chances he generated in comparison with his playing time.
Keeping Matri just because he plays as a cente forward is not wise, as i do not believe in his attitude and composure in front of goal. Matri is not bad, but i find quags to be more mentally prepared when called upon. Thats all.
- - - Updated - - -
His first goal in the away celtic game was decisive, but kinda lucky.
Quags goal against chelsea was clever, and he almost won us the game when he rattled the bar minutes after.
Matri is not composed in front of goal, and he tends to "just kick the ball and hope for the best" most of the time. He seems to not be as accurate or intelligent. Thats my impression of him. Quags also kicks it like a madman sometimes... but i like his attitude more (but not his constant whinning to his teammates

)