Xabi Alonso (51 Viewers)

After the Poulsen signing, will Secco, Blanc and cie still buy Xabi Alonso?

  • YES

  • NO


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Djabrail

Senior Member
May 23, 2008
1,115
Sure, and i didnt say we need to change him, all i saying we need somebody to cover a second spot at CB, and this somebody must be way better LEGRO. He must be at least the same quality as Chiellini. And Chiellini needs to be more cool. I think it will come with more expierence as CB.
 

Hust

Senior Member
Hustini
May 29, 2005
93,703
Giovinco is the one who'll take us to the next level.
Too optimistic ? Perhaps, but everything points out to Giovinco becomming the new star of our team and of world's football. Our game will depend on him mostly and all we'll need is a strong group around Giovinco.

Buying players like vdV will be useless at the moment. We'll take a gamble with Giovinco (if it's a gamble at all, considering how good Gio is) and we'll add team players.

Our first team was pretty good. We've beaten Milan, Inter, Roma and they couldn't beat us. We lack consistency and that's because the gap between our first team and our reserves was pretty big. When Mancini was resting his best players, or when they were injured, he always had good players on the bench to replace them. That's why Inter had more pts than us. Ranieri couldn't do that and he either had below average players to work with or he had to overplay our best players.
Now we need to replace players like Almiron, Molinaro, Legrotagllie, Tiago, Palladino, Nocerino with better players (but not 30m eur worth superstars), players like Amauri, Alonso, Grosso and i think we're ready to go.

Having Zanetti, Amauri, Nedved and similar players on the bench will make us much stronger because the bench plays a huge role in long championships.
Great post man, Giovinco looks like our future leader. I was watching him in the Toulan tourney in France. He is sooo quick with his distribution and his creativity is great. I know its only a u21 tourney but you can see what the fuss is all about. Why spend money on a creative player when we already have a young maestro?? Spend money to put great players around him that he can play with and develop around. Xabi would be great, our passing game would go up immensely and add giovinco to the equation and we have a much "prettier" football that i cant wait to see. Lets make money selling everyone you mentioned. Amauri, Alonso, and Grosso (or Vargas) are going to make us so much stronger. And who knows maybe Ekdal will turn out to be a dynamo?
 

Brixity

Senior Member
Feb 8, 2006
1,332
Xabi Alonso would be great. I'm just hoping we dont pay insane amounts for him but he would definately improve us and not to mention the quality of depth him coming entails. I'm also hoping for Grosso though. And how the hell is Chiellini not world class - the number of times that dude bailed us out of Molinaro's slip ups are countless. Not to mention his grit and good positioning
 

Dominic

Senior Member
Jan 30, 2004
16,706
Giovinco is the one who'll take us to the next level.
Too optimistic ? Perhaps, but everything points out to Giovinco becomming the new star of our team and of world's football. Our game will depend on him mostly and all we'll need is a strong group around Giovinco.

Buying players like vdV will be useless at the moment. We'll take a gamble with Giovinco (if it's a gamble at all, considering how good Gio is) and we'll add team players.

Our first team was pretty good. We've beaten Milan, Inter, Roma and they couldn't beat us. We lack consistency and that's because the gap between our first team and our reserves was pretty big. When Mancini was resting his best players, or when they were injured, he always had good players on the bench to replace them. That's why Inter had more pts than us. Ranieri couldn't do that and he either had below average players to work with or he had to overplay our best players.
Now we need to replace players like Almiron, Molinaro, Legrotagllie, Tiago, Palladino, Nocerino with better players (but not 30m eur worth superstars), players like Amauri, Alonso, Grosso and i think we're ready to go.

Having Zanetti, Amauri, Nedved and similar players on the bench will make us much stronger because the bench plays a huge role in long championships.
I agree with what you're saying, but this is one of the two things that could kill Giovinco. The pressure/expectations and lack of space. The second might happen, but will be solved by Giovinco being placed on the left of the midfield, but I think his 'true' role is more upfront(even if he doesn't think so himself). A role he'll rarely to never get to play with DP, Amauri and Iaquinta in competition for his spot. And thus he will somewhat forced to show his play in a position that may not be truely his.

Nedved will be the starter from the beginning and it's up to Giovinco to break into the team, which may lead to forceful performances (see Palladino: doing overcomplicated things at the wrong time, just because he wants and needs to prove himself). Next season could prove dangerous for Giovinco, but in the end it's up to him (and Ranieri a bit) to prove that wrong.
 

HelterSkelter

Senior Member
Apr 15, 2005
20,567
Even if we are going to sign Alonso,i dont think we'd be able to do so before the Euros.And that is not good for us.The later it goes on,the more teams will come into the equation,including Real FUCKING Madrid.

I just hope he has a pathetic Euro..misses like,7 penalties,scores 10 own goals..and does a Joey Barton on David Villa.
 

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,661
Well said, but most of what you said is still arguable.
We have no idea how big is our transfer budget. Amauri and Xabi Alonso cost circa 30m euro (+Nocerino and half of Lanzafame).
Since Juve are selling Tiago, Marchionni and Almiron (and since Blasi is finally sold), it's expected the money spent for Alonso to be compensated with the money we'll get from the sales of the above mentioned players (probably some 1 or 2m left for Juve).
As you said, there are no superstar LB's, no Roberto Carlos on the market. The LB we'll buy will cost 4,5,6,7m euro.

To sumarize, the money we're paying for Amauri and the money we'll spend on LB, around 17-18m total, are the only money Juve will be paying.
Then there is Criscito, wanted by Genoa (they offer 3m eur, Juve want 5.5m) and even Molinaro. I'm sure some mid-table teams will be ready to pay some small sum for a player who was a regular in Juve, as bad as he was.

Selling these two and we're left with some 10-13m , lets call it cash money, that Juve will be paying.

If these 10-13m will stop us from buying a quality CB then buying Amauri is maybe a mistake.
But if such a, relatively small, sum will stop us from buying a quality CB then we don't even deserve to buy a CB.

So it's a question of our budget actually. If our budget was 40-50m eur (not counting player's sales) then there will be no problems. But we don't know if the 40-50 millions were newspaper speculations or a fact.
Personally, I doubt our directors would have bought Amauri if our budget was so limited.
That's what I thought, but I was just going with the flow of the thread and assuming the worst. Even so Juve have plenty of room to by a solid left back and even a decent CB, I'm not talking a Micah Richards or Carlos Puyol, but probably someone better than Legro.
 

Jim_Boi

Senior Member
Oct 7, 2007
1,548
Giovinco is the one who'll take us to the next level.
Too optimistic ? Perhaps, but everything points out to Giovinco becomming the new star of our team and of world's football. Our game will depend on him mostly and all we'll need is a strong group around Giovinco.

Buying players like vdV will be useless at the moment. We'll take a gamble with Giovinco (if it's a gamble at all, considering how good Gio is) and we'll add team players.

Our first team was pretty good. We've beaten Milan, Inter, Roma and they couldn't beat us. We lack consistency and that's because the gap between our first team and our reserves was pretty big. When Mancini was resting his best players, or when they were injured, he always had good players on the bench to replace them. That's why Inter had more pts than us. Ranieri couldn't do that and he either had below average players to work with or he had to overplay our best players.
Now we need to replace players like Almiron, Molinaro, Legrotagllie, Tiago, Palladino, Nocerino with better players (but not 30m eur worth superstars), players like Amauri, Alonso, Grosso and i think we're ready to go.

Having Zanetti, Amauri, Nedved and similar players on the bench will make us much stronger because the bench plays a huge role in long championships.
:tup:
 

Dostoevsky

Tzu
Administrator
May 27, 2007
88,988
I agree with what you're saying, but this is one of the two things that could kill Giovinco. The pressure/expectations and lack of space. The second might happen, but will be solved by Giovinco being placed on the left of the midfield, but I think his 'true' role is more upfront(even if he doesn't think so himself). A role he'll rarely to never get to play with DP, Amauri and Iaquinta in competition for his spot. And thus he will somewhat forced to show his play in a position that may not be truely his.

Nedved will be the starter from the beginning and it's up to Giovinco to break into the team, which may lead to forceful performances (see Palladino: doing overcomplicated things at the wrong time, just because he wants and needs to prove himself). Next season could prove dangerous for Giovinco, but in the end it's up to him (and Ranieri a bit) to prove that wrong.
Come on now.The boy didn't even start playing for us and you are searching for his possible failures?

Giovinco is a great player and has great deal of potential but it's time for him to step in to the next level.I have very high hopes for him and we should throw him into the fire this season.I presonaly think he's going to prove his quality but stop thinking now if he's going to fail because of the high expectations.It's time for him to prove himself.

How do you think lets say Aguero will feel the pressure if he comes to replace Del Piero?Sure,it's not easy to get on with but it's right time to prove he's world class player.

I know a lot of the guys here hate C.Ronaldo because he's arrogant fucktartd but he's been amazing this season.He was thrown at fire but in the end he came out as great player.
 

Dominic

Senior Member
Jan 30, 2004
16,706
That's completely besides my point, dule. I'm putting it in a larger perspective, showing the other side of the coin.

Wether or not he is good enough, there are more factors to consider. The pressure on him is almost unprecedented high(remember, he's just 21, with only one season of serie A experience, while we're all raving about him crazily and expect him to win a starting place from the get-go and be amongst the cl's and serie a's topperformers).

Also looking at former examples like Palladino (I know Giovinco is on another level), should tell is it won't be so simple for him. I mean you shout about Aguero to replace Del Piero.. What would happen if we actually signed Aguero? Aguero would get wasted. He'd have to compete with monsters like Iaquinta, Amauri and on top of that Del Piero. The Icon who'll have turin on it's head if he doesn't start for two matches in a row. Same with Giovinco, who'll have to adopt midfield role, probably Nedved's role. Who always played on power and is always kept because tactically coaches love him for his alround and defensive abilities. Giovinco is a different type of player. A player you should set loose creatively in the final third.

What competition did Ronaldo have? He was allowed to grow in his own role for three years.

Just consider these points, before you already crown Giovinco as juve's saviour.
 

Roman

-'Tuz Fantasy Master-
Apr 19, 2003
10,778
Even if we are going to sign Alonso,i dont think we'd be able to do so before the Euros.And that is not good for us.The later it goes on,the more teams will come into the equation,including Real FUCKING Madrid.

I just hope he has a pathetic Euro..misses like,7 penalties,scores 10 own goals..and does a Joey Barton on David Villa.
:lol:
Yeah his agent said so,they will decide after the Euro.crap.

"I have a clear idea, namely Liverpool would like to sell. But we must first speak with Rafa Benitez," he told local reporters as he left a meeting with the Bianconeri brass at the club's headquarters.

"We'll decide after the European Championships," the agent added.


http://www.goal.com/en/Articolo.aspx?ContenutoId=715203

I hope Real doesn't join the race,and he'll make the right choice.
Forza Xabi!
 

Osman

Koul Khara!
Aug 30, 2002
61,489
That's completely besides my point, dule. I'm putting it in a larger perspective, showing the other side of the coin.

Wether or not he is good enough, there are more factors to consider. The pressure on him is almost unprecedented high(remember, he's just 21, with only one season of serie A experience, while we're all raving about him crazily and expect him to win a starting place from the get-go and be amongst the cl's and serie a's topperformers).

Also looking at former examples like Palladino (I know Giovinco is on another level), should tell is it won't be so simple for him. I mean you shout about Aguero to replace Del Piero.. What would happen if we actually signed Aguero? Aguero would get wasted. He'd have to compete with monsters like Iaquinta, Amauri and on top of that Del Piero. The Icon who'll have turin on it's head if he doesn't start for two matches in a row. Same with Giovinco, who'll have to adopt midfield role, probably Nedved's role. Who always played on power and is always kept because tactically coaches love him for his alround and defensive abilities. Giovinco is a different type of player. A player you should set loose creatively in the final third.

What competition did Ronaldo have? He was allowed to grow in his own role for three years.

Just consider these points, before you already crown Giovinco as juve's saviour.

I agree there is a point where expectations get too much. But you are sounding too pragmatic for the sake of it in parts. If they are huge talents enough, then just play them and they will show whats what. For example, I dont get your Aguero bit. He like TOOOOOYED with everyone like I have never seen anyone do before in the U-20 WC last summer (not even Messi was that dominating for U-20 argies). He has scored 18 La Liga goals this season, and he has had jawdropping games like scoring 2 goals against Barcelona and almost single handedly winning them the game.

If you show stuff like that, why say stuff like he would be wasted and crushed by our attackers? He is in another level to the likes of Amauri, Iaquinta, and he would give 34 year old Del Piero a run for his money and eventually bench him.


Giovinco is in similar scope of talent. Yes its useful to take it slow, but if he shows he is such a bonafide talent its unreal, then you should trust his abilities and expect him to what he can do. Young players can suffer if they are pressured too much, but if the big talent is there, there is as equal amount of examples of them rising above it and showing their stuff as they should.
 

HelterSkelter

Senior Member
Apr 15, 2005
20,567
:lol:
Yeah his agent said so,they will decide after the Euro.crap.

"I have a clear idea, namely Liverpool would like to sell. But we must first speak with Rafa Benitez," he told local reporters as he left a meeting with the Bianconeri brass at the club's headquarters.

"We'll decide after the European Championships," the agent added.


http://www.goal.com/en/Articolo.aspx?ContenutoId=715203

I hope Real doesn't join the race,and he'll make the right choice.
Forza Xabi!
That plain sucks:mad:

Liverpool will get a long distance call from Madrid now.
 

Dominic

Senior Member
Jan 30, 2004
16,706
I agree there is a point where expectations get too much. But you are sounding too pragmatic for the sake of it in parts. If they are huge talents enough, then just play them and they will show whats what. For example, I dont get your Aguero bit. He like TOOOOOYED with everyone like I have never seen anyone do before in the U-20 WC last summer (not even Messi was that dominating for U-20 argies). He has scored 18 La Liga goals this season, and he has had jawdropping games like scoring 2 goals against Barcelona and almost single handedly winning them the game.

If you show stuff like that, why say stuff like he would be wasted and crushed by our attackers? He is in another level to the likes of Amauri, Iaquinta, and he would give 34 year old Del Piero a run for his money and eventually bench him.


Giovinco is in similar scope of talent. Yes its useful to take it slow, but if he shows he is such a bonafide talent its unreal, then you should trust his abilities and expect him to what he can do. Young players can suffer if they are pressured too much, but if the big talent is there, there is as equal amount of examples of them rising above it and showing their stuff as they should.
Again, besides the point. Giovinco is good enough, of course. I'm saying that there are more factors to weigh in, which could lead to dissapointment and Giovinco not living up to expectations.

These u-21 tell us that Giovinco and Aguero are way ahead of the players of the same generation. But it doesn't say that they are ahead of the best players.

Even these type of special talents would find it difficult to find space and youngsters needs playing time, confidence and some consistency more than anything. If not, they'll over start overcomplecating to show their worth. When a youngster like Aguero is allowed to fully express himself without competition, you'll see a completely different player from one who chokes and has to struggle for minutes.

Anyway, I firmly beleive Giovinco has what it takes, but we can't assume anything.. these talents are so fragile.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 51)