
He isn't way better. He has shown that on top of his game he is better atm. Both Gaitan and Hulk are going to show what they are made of in the next 5 years. Robben will be done and dusted in 4. At least people noted he is constantly injured or getting into shape. There goes the second big no-no :"Robben being signed as key player would be a dream, not a bad choice

... "

Great, lets get a key player that will play maximum say 30% of the season. Out of that he will be in his top form say 20%(too generous, perhaps?) or 10% of the time... 1 out of 5-10 games and a key player salary wise?
Epic fail! Now should we buy Muller as a backup(de facto our starter) as well? Or get Gaitan to be that backup?
That is why its actually better to get Gaitan and be done with it.
Hulk can cross, beats his man one on one and is creative in the wide areas. While not out and out winger, he is great in a 3 man attack and can play on both flanks. He was so much better than what we have.
about the 4:
1.Messi;2.C.Ronaldo;3.Sanchez;4.Iniesta;5.Ribery;6.Silva... Neymar?...
We will soon see how Ashley Young will go forward, but his first half of the season he is a mirror image of Robben. Certainly without the full skill set of Robben at his best, but he is playing quite the same game perfectly, just instead of a left-footed winger on the right he is a right-footed winger on the left.