cathereth is likeable ill give him that...but as we have seen, he is prone to mistakes and rash tackles (which may be costly). i havent followed him in sevilla but i do watch him when uruguay plays and he does impress me a lot..he is relatively young meaning that there is still time for him to sort out the irregularities in his tackling, positioning etc that is if they are still present. I'd take him also because of his versatility along the back line. he has that grinta already in him and he is eager to come back to wear our shirt...saying better can be done is not the same as better will be done..so, ill take him..