What is your god like? (17 Viewers)

[Martin]

Pay more attention to the context Martin

Mohammed is lie (or) Mohammed isn't lying = TRUE.

I'm trying to prove Mohammed isn't lying but since 7 is wasting his time on proving NOTHING I thought I should give him a small hint

You are trying to prove that Mohammed isn't lying by saying "Mohammed is lie (or) Mohammed isn't lying = TRUE"? This is your proof?

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Seven]

How do you expect me to respond, seriously?

I have no idea. I thought it was a very silly question of you to begin with.

 

[DelpieroForLife]

You are trying to prove that Mohammed isn't lying by saying "Mohammed is lie (or) Mohammed isn't lying = TRUE"? This is your proof?

No.

Martin please read the entire page.

 

[Fred]

You're only defending him because he's muslim. Not even you think he's writing posts that make sense.

I'm not defending anybody. Eariler I said that you always resort to insults in the end, you replied to me by saying that it was DP for life that resorts to insults, now you've contradicted yourself and proved me right.

 

[Martin]

No.

Martin please read the entire page.

I have. I still have no idea what you're doing.

 

[DelpieroForLife]

I have no idea. I thought it was a very silly question of you to begin with.

You think I'm stupid why do you feel surprised when I ask a silly question?

 

[Seven]

I'm not defending anybody. Eariler I said that you always resort to insults in the end, you replied to me by saying that it was DP for life that resorts to insults, now you've contradicted yourself and proved me right.

What is with muslims and the incapacity to understand the meaning of words?

 

[Fred]

Wait, i don't understand. So now you guys are saying Muhammad(PBUH) was lying, and that he wasn't illiterate?

 

[Seven]

You think I'm stupid why do you feel surprised when I ask a silly question?

I didn't say I was surprised. I said it was a silly question. Don't put words in my mouth.

 

[Seven]

Wait, i don't understand. So now you guys are saying Muhammad(PBUH) was lying, and that he wasn't illiterate?

That's what we've always said.

More accurately: we said it was a possibility.

The conclusion was that DPFL had to prove two things:

a) Muhammad was illiterate
b) Muhammad acted alone

He did no such thing.

 

[Fred]

What is with muslims and the incapacity to understand the meaning of words?

So you're associating muslims with stupidity right? As in when you're a muslim you have an incapacity to understand the meaning of words? Then when we say that you're a bigot, you say you're not?

Actually just by looking at my sig, it shows your incapacity to look at anything objectively.

 

[Martin]

Wait, i don't understand. So now you guys are saying Muhammad(PBUH) was lying, and that he wasn't illiterate?

Seven said you can't prove he wasn't lying.

 

[DelpieroForLife]

I have. I still have no idea what you're doing.

7 was trying to prove that Mohammed could be lying.

I explained to him that:

Mohammed is lying (or) Mohammed isn't lying = TRUE.

Which say absolutely NOTHING and need NO prove to start with.

I didn't use it to prove Mohammed isn't lying.

 

[Fred]

That's what we've always said.

More accurately: we said it was a possibility.

The conclusion was that DPFL had to prove two things:

a) Muhammad was illiterate
b) Muhammad acted alone

He did no such thing.

The burden of proof was on him because......?


You made the claim that there was a possibility that he faked the whole thing. So its on you to prove it.

 

[Martin]

I didn't use it to prove Mohammed isn't lying.

So when are you going to?

 

[DelpieroForLife]

Wait, i don't understand. So now you guys are saying Muhammad(PBUH) was lying, and that he wasn't illiterate?

How could you possibly miss that one Fred

 

[Fred]

Seven said you can't prove he wasn't lying.

I am saying that he can't prove otherwise either. He made the claim, he should support it with evidence.

 

[Seven]

The burden of proof was on him because......?


You made the claim that there was a possibility that he faked the whole thing. So its on you to prove it.

Because he said it wasn't possible. The burden of proof is on him, because he has to exclude the possibility.

This is mere logics, fred.

 

[Martin]

The burden of proof was on him because......?

Because he's claiming this to begin with.

- So this guy got this book from god.
- Prove it.
- But he did.
- He could be lying.
- Prove that he was lying.

wtf?

How many more times do I have to paste that cartoon?

 

[Seven]

I am saying that he can't prove otherwise either. He made the claim, he should support it with evidence.

I did. Joseph Smith.

And my claim was that you can't prove he didn't lie.
My claim was not that he lied.

Two very different things.