There's often disagreement. But if mods erred on the side of overruling each other's actions instead of supporting each other's decisions or actions, this place would look a lot more like last night all the time.
Ban. No ban. Infraction. No infraction. Fight fight fight.
It's bad enough when the posters are being sh*t-disturbers with each other for the mods to then join in and do the same among themselves.