Was it a smart move or not? (1 Viewer)

Desmond

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2002
8,938
#21
++ [ originally posted by swag ] ++
By trading away Maresca and Appiah, we got a player who was about as good as the two of them combined -- and astronomically more capable of bringing us closer to a CL win than any of the others.
Indeed.With Vieira being as good as Maresca and Appiah put together the simple equation is that with Emerson around we could play one Vieira but not the two of Maresca and Appiah - then there's also Blasi.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com
Apr 12, 2004
77,165
#22
Of course it was a smart move. Maresca is not half the player of Vieira and while Appiah IMO is a decent player, he certainly is worth giving up for Vieira. Although I do think Appiah will improve over time, and when Vieira and Emerson move on you might regret giving up on Appiah because he does have a lot of potential. Perhaps in Istanbul Appiah will improve greatly, and thus far I think he has played very well next to the likes of Alex and Anelka.

As for Vieira, his form thus far this season has been impeccable, and he is probably the most complete middy in the world today. Andy told me Vieira has not set a foot wrong on the pitch yet for the Bianconeri, and from what I have seen that assessment is certainly correct. I am also impressed with the passion Vieira has shown on the pitch, and it's probably a joy for him to play for such a prestigious club and challenge for the prestigious Champions League title. With the way Juventus has played thus far, I would say the CL title is a great possibility.
 

Maher

Juventuz addict
Dec 16, 2002
13,521
#28
++ [ originally posted by DelpieroForLife ] ++
We can sacrify 9 Maresca's and 12 Appiah's in order to land Vieria and it still considered as a brilliant move...

Sad But True...
for the first time , i agree with you
 

Primo

Juventus FC - Philippines
Dec 20, 2002
1,436
#33
Honestly, If Juve were building a team for the future. Maresca would be our best option. But Juve wanted results right away, more so, they want to capture the Champions League immediately so we brought in an established champion such as Vieira.

For me, it was a good buy. Actually, we got a bargain considering that we got him for less than 18M which is how I would appraise his value at the moment. Good thing he didn't have quite a good year in Arsenal the previous year, that shaved off a few million dollars from his tag price.
 

Primo

Juventus FC - Philippines
Dec 20, 2002
1,436
#34
++ [ originally posted by Bürke ] ++

As for Vieira, his form thus far this season has been impeccable, and he is probably the most complete middy in the world today. Andy told me Vieira has not set a foot wrong on the pitch yet for the Bianconeri, and from what I have seen that assessment is certainly correct. I am also impressed with the passion Vieira has shown on the pitch, and it's probably a joy for him to play for such a prestigious club and challenge for the prestigious Champions League title. With the way Juventus has played thus far, I would say the CL title is a great possibility.
The experience he's having with Juve right now is perhaps what he really wanted that he didn't have at Arsenal. Juve are making waves in Europe and this was something he couldn't find in London.

I have to agree with you, CL looks like a great possibility with Vieira on board.
 

Zlatan

Senior Member
Jun 9, 2003
23,049
#37
++ [ originally posted by Primo ] ++
Honestly, If Juve were building a team for the future. Maresca would be our best option. But Juve wanted results right away, more so, they want to capture the Champions League immediately so we brought in an established champion such as Vieira.

For me, it was a good buy. Actually, we got a bargain considering that we got him for less than 18M which is how I would appraise his value at the moment. Good thing he didn't have quite a good year in Arsenal the previous year, that shaved off a few million dollars from his tag price.

Actually, we got him for exactly 20 mil €.
 

Adrian

Senior Member
Jan 31, 2003
6,872
#38
the only negative to selling maresca and appiah is that they were the only two way midfielders available to replace Vieira and Emerson.

Vieira and Emerson is the best thing since slice bread, but when you have Blasi and Giannichedda as back up, that bread suddenly becomes mouldy.

Hence, i think the club should have looked at selling others before selling both maresca and appiah.

For me, I would have kept Maresca and looked at selling a player like Zalayeta to raise the funds.

Or even sell Blasi before Maresca.
 

djleli

Senior Member
Aug 12, 2004
3,579
#40
the best buy this summer :D, under capello we have done the best deals ever, we got cannavaro, ibrahimovic and viera he surly is one heck of a tecnichian
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)