Trezeguet out , Klose in ? (13 Viewers)

Alfio_87 · Dec 2, 2006

why would he leave anyway Werder are travelling well they play attackive and attractive football must be loving it to have that gun Diego running behind him and they also have a real chance to progess next round of CL at expense of Barca! Leave him dere, we keep Trez!

Falafel · Dec 2, 2006

Alfio_87 said:

but he stated that he wants to play outside of germany

Arvin · Dec 2, 2006

klose is good but he is old, after two season he is 30. i want villa and after 4 or 5 season he became 30 until than we have good chances to win...everything.

Geof · Dec 2, 2006

Ok I got over the fact that I didn't like Klose.

In fact, the day after I said these things in this thread I saw a huge Nike banner in the middle of Berlin, with Miroslav on it. looked kinda cool.

Anyway, I reckon that Klose is a great player. Speed, finishing and heading are his main assets, this kind can net goals maybe a bit less than Trez, but he beats David when it comes to speed and to run aound the pitch, helping the midfield when needed.

He's also a great pro. Never heard a bad word about him. Did well with Werder and Germany.

And, he'd also be available for an ok price.

The only minus point is that I heard that he doesn't speak any foreign languages, not even English. That could be a small problem, for his integration and all. In our squad, I only see Kovac speaking German, so Miro'd better buy an assimil if he comes to Turin.

Conclusion: IMO Klose is a very good Trez replacement. Possibly the best replacement in a reachable price. But seeing him in the bianconero shirt will include seeing Trez leave to Lyon I guess.
If David wants to compete for the CL, I'm all in for a Miro capture.

Klose, DP, Boji, Palla, (5th str), is a very good frontline imo.

Geof · Dec 2, 2006

Alfio_87 said:

well, the move would only happen this summer. Let his enjoy his CL with Werder, because next year, he might not play it.

ADiGATi0N · Dec 2, 2006

I do not think Klose will be thinking in Juventus and I do not think he can be a good player in the Calcio. David Villa is much better but I dont think he will go to Juventus since he has a high price whic other clubs will agree on

Jun-hide · Dec 2, 2006

Andy said:

:rofl2:

Had a good laugh over that one.

IMHO Trez is a better option by far considering various factors but I just do not think it is right to keep a player against his wishes and he would contribute to our cause in Serie B. If Camo, Buffon, or Trez wants CL football next year, then I think as a fan we should let them go.

Klose is not a bad substitute no doubt - but I think the money could be a real issue. As far as I am concerned Klose is leaving because I just cant imagine Werder being able to match the salaries that is going to be offered to him by big European clubs (BTW, I think Man U might join in this hunt some time soon). Also, the domestic factor would play a part too. Bundesliga is not the powerhouse it used to be throughout 80s to mid 90s. And no disrespect to Werder, Juve is far bigger club in all regards and it is matter of time before we start competiting for top spots in Europe (though Klose might be too old by then). For Klose Juve makes a perfect career sense. Guaranteed first team slot, more money, better competition.

Gill_juve · Dec 2, 2006

get klose hes scored 12 goals in 14 league games, sick, while trez is injured lol

Paolo Sosa · Dec 2, 2006

about age, german players seem to shine in their 30's

Klose11Werder · Dec 2, 2006

You could be sad that Klose wont come to Juve.
You dont know his qualities, but doesnt matter.
Very poor, some comments.

Today he played again fantastic. 2 great goals.

Jun-hide · Dec 2, 2006

Gill_juve said:

Form is temporary and class is permanent. You don't need statistician to prove Bayensian probability update to know that.

Trez has been by far the more prolific goal scorer with higher game-goal ratio, more goals, tougher domestic league, more experience at an international stage (there is more than just couple of games in World Cup after all though many including FIFA forget about this), European stage. The matter of fact is Trez has been by far the better goal-scorer in his career than Klose and nothing is going to change that. To be fair though, Klose seems to be a bit of late-boomer so the discrepancies isnt as big as the stat might suggest.

IMO the key issue is not about Klose. I think he is very good player. Its about Trezeguet. Will he stay or not? I don't know the answer to this.

Zé Tahir · Dec 2, 2006

Why do you sign up here to tell us how he shouldn't come here. I mean, are you bored? Why don't you scratch your ass or something.

pUnk · Dec 2, 2006

i think klose it's to old for a club like juve. Trezeguet is much better

Gill_juve · Dec 2, 2006

Jun-hide said:

Form is temporary and class is permanent. You don't need statistician to prove Bayensian probability update to know that.

Trez has been by far the more prolific goal scorer with higher game-goal ratio, more goals, tougher domestic league, more experience at an international stage (there is more than just couple of games in World Cup after all though many including FIFA forget about this), European stage. The matter of fact is Trez has been by far the better goal-scorer in his career than Klose and nothing is going to change that. To be fair though, Klose seems to be a bit of late-boomer so the discrepancies isnt as big as the stat might suggest.

IMO the key issue is not about Klose. I think he is very good player. Its about Trezeguet. Will he stay or not? I don't know the answer to this.

yeh ok but stats do matter but it was just a comment

ReBeL · Dec 2, 2006

Zé Tahir said:

That's the most accurate description for this newbie's case...

Alltagsheld · Dec 2, 2006

Klose11Werder said:

Both of us know, Miro is going to leave soon, probably at the end of this season. That hurts, but if I would like to see him anywhere else, then at Juve!!!

Morra10 · Dec 2, 2006

klose is world class. i want him if / when trez leaves. amazing how some people wouldnt want him?

Adrian · Dec 3, 2006

id rather the club used common sense and make a swap with buffon for adriano plus cash. Adriano has serie A experience, is better than Klose and will play for many seasons.

Trez leaving wouldnt be such a bad thing considering his injuries and age..he'll be 30, and with his long list of injuries, he wont be around in 3 or so seasons playing at his peak.

Jun-hide · Dec 3, 2006

Gill_juve said:

I understand, and I do also believe Klose is a good player. At this moment of time I do not think the discrepancies between Trezeguet and Klose certainly as wide as the stats suggests. But I just want to point out I cannot imagine any discussion on Klose without Trezeguet being sacrificed or leave (whatever interpretation you take). And for me, Trezeguet is a priority.

We should discuss Klose only after Trezeguet situation is cleared up. All regards though considering his contract status I do not think he will fetch astronomical sums and despite his fame could be good value for money. But we should not forget real life is not like a video game where people can automatically adjust to their surrounings easily. Look at Sheva. Players are not robots that plays at their best regardless of environment that surrounds them (ask Adriano about that) and at age 30 you don't get the second chance that maybe 21 year might get.

Bjerknes · Dec 3, 2006

Jun-hide said:

It's the truth though.

Seriously, I can't stand Miroslav Klose. He's nowhere near as good as Trezeguet in front of goal.

Trezeguet out , Klose in ? (13 Viewers)

Senior Member

Shawarma

Juve Star

Senior Member

Senior Member

Junior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

New Member

Senior Member

JhoolayLaaaal!

Junior Member

Senior Member

The Jackal

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

"Top Economist"

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 13)