Tommason (1 Viewer)

May 4, 2004
11,622
#82
IMO, this season:

In Serie A Only!

Dida - Buffon (1 - 1)
Cafu - Zebina (1 - 0)
Stam - Thuram (0 - 1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (0 - 1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (1 - 1)
Gattuso - Emerson (0 - 1)
Pirlo - Blasi (5 - 0)
Kaka - Nedved (1 - 0)
Seedorf - Cammo (0 - 1)
Sheva - Zlatan (0 - 1)
Crespo - Del Piero (1 - 1)
 

Zlatan

Senior Member
Jun 9, 2003
23,049
#83
++ [ originally posted by Dan ] ++


I would say this season Nesta has been slightly better. However, Fabio is almost equal becuase of crucial goals he has scored.

Camo might of been a revalation this season, but is not as good as Seedorf IMO.

I'm talking about this seasons form, and IMO Camo has been more important for the team and in better form this season, as IMO has Cannavaro, not that Nesta has been bad, far from it.


++ [ originally posted by Menace ] ++
same can be said about shev but you still say hes been better then zlatan

Are we forgetting that Shevchenko scored 6 crucial CL goals? :rolleyes:
 

Dan

Back & Quack
Mar 9, 2004
9,290
#84
++ [ originally posted by Menace ] ++
same can be said about shev but you still say hes been better then zlatan
of course he has. Jezas, are you focking blind or something? Zlatan did not score in the CL. Whilst he was undoubtedly good, Sheva has been at his usual great standards.
 

Zlatan

Senior Member
Jun 9, 2003
23,049
#85
++ [ originally posted by Juve_Kosova ] ++
IMO, this season:
In Serie A Only!
Dida - Buffon (1 - 1)
Cafu - Zebina (1 - 0)
Stam - Thuram (0 - 1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (0 - 1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (1 - 1)
Gattuso - Emerson (0 - 1)
Pirlo - Blasi (5 - 0)
Kaka - Nedved (1 - 0)
Seedorf - Cammo (0 - 1)
Sheva - Zlatan (0 - 1)
Crespo - Del Piero (1 - 1)

:rolleyes:


BTW, you cant really watch the seria A, if you're comparing players you should compaer their overall season.
 

Dan

Back & Quack
Mar 9, 2004
9,290
#86
++ [ originally posted by Juve_Kosova ] ++
IMO, this season:

In Serie A Only!

Dida - Buffon (1 - 1)
Cafu - Zebina (1 - 0)
Stam - Thuram (0 - 1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (0 - 1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (1 - 1)
Gattuso - Emerson (0 - 1)
Pirlo - Blasi (5 - 0)
Kaka - Nedved (1 - 0)
Seedorf - Cammo (0 - 1)
Sheva - Zlatan (0 - 1)
Crespo - Del Piero (1 - 1)
The last two are a joke man..
 

JCK

Biased
JCK
May 11, 2004
123,580
#87
++ [ originally posted by Menace ] ++
same can be said about shev but you still say hes been better then zlatan
Of course Sheva was better, how many goals have Sheva scored in the CL and how many have Zlatan scored?

Ok, Zlatan has ONE more goal in the championship than Sheva, does this make him better.

Go back to the games and see the teams that Sheva has scored against and the teams that Zlatan have scored against.
 

Dan

Back & Quack
Mar 9, 2004
9,290
#89
++ [ originally posted by Zlatan ] ++



I'm talking about this seasons form, and IMO Camo has been more important for the team and in better form this season, as IMO has Cannavaro, not that Nesta has been bad, far from it.
Thats debateable. But im gonna leave it as this because its obvious we wont come to a conclusion as to has been better, they are pretty much on par with each other anyway.
 

Zlatan

Senior Member
Jun 9, 2003
23,049
#92
Shevchenko has a better game to goal ratio, and you cant simply ignore his 6 CL goals, nor can you ignore Crespo's crucial goals in the CL.
 
May 4, 2004
11,622
#94
++ [ originally posted by Zlatan ] ++
Shevchenko has a better game to goal ratio, and you cant simply ignore his 6 CL goals, nor can you ignore Crespo's crucial goals in the CL.
True.. if u talk about the hole season in all leagues then Sheva has been better then Zlatan! yes!
 

JCK

Biased
JCK
May 11, 2004
123,580
#95
++ [ originally posted by Andy ] ++
Did I just see somebody rate Ibrahimovic higher than Shevchenko? Seriously, do people watch any football around here?
Let go Andy, they laugh at you if you say otherwise.

You might even be accused of not being a Juventus fan
 

arc

Senior Member
Mar 11, 2004
4,077
#97
looks like everyone having fun doing this, my rating
season0405
Dida - Buffon (milan+1, 1-0)
Cafu - Zebina (milan+3, 4-0)
Stam - Thuram (juve+1, 4-1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (juve+1, 4-2)
Maldini - Zambrotta (juve+1, 4-3)
Gattuso - Emerson (tie, 4-3)
Pirlo - Blasi (milan+4, 8-3)
Kaka - Nedved (milan+1, 9-3)
Seedorf - Camo (juve+1, 9-4)
Sheva - Zlatan (milan+1, 10-4)
Crespo - Del Piero (milan+2, 12-4)

general
Dida - Buffon (juve+1, 0-1)
Cafu - Zebina (milan+2, 2-1)
Stam - Thuram (tie, 2-1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (milan+1, 3-1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (juve+1, 3-2)
Gattuso - Emerson (juve +1, 3-3)
Pirlo - Blasi (milan+4, 7-3)
Kaka - Nedved (tie, 7-3)
Seedorf - Camo (milan+1, 8-3)
Sheva - Zlatan (milan+1, 10-3)
Crespo - Del Piero (i duno..)
 

Menace

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2005
3,988
#98
++ [ originally posted by Juve_Kosova ] ++
IMO, this season:

In Serie A Only!

Dida - Buffon (1 - 1)
Cafu - Zebina (1 - 0)
Stam - Thuram (0 - 1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (0 - 1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (1 - 1)
Gattuso - Emerson (0 - 1)
Pirlo - Blasi (5 - 0)
Kaka - Nedved (1 - 0)
Seedorf - Cammo (0 - 1)
Sheva - Zlatan (0 - 1)
Crespo - Del Piero (1 - 1)
thats a fair review
 

Menace

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2005
3,988
#99
++ [ originally posted by Jeeks ] ++


Of course Sheva was better, how many goals have Sheva scored in the CL and how many have Zlatan scored?

Ok, Zlatan has ONE more goal in the championship than Sheva, does this make him better.

Go back to the games and see the teams that Sheva has scored against and the teams that Zlatan have scored against.
are forgetting zlatans assits he carried our attack by himself
overall zlatan had a better season
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)