Tommason (4 Viewers)

arc · Apr 28, 2005

sorrie but i have to disagree with this

anyway

Sadomin · Apr 28, 2005

Dida, Cafu and Stam are better/in better form than those Juve players. However I rank Cannavaro higher than Nesta, since he looks much more determined and energetic when he plays.

Edge · Apr 28, 2005

Shall we do a comparison then.

Ok, made a slight error, now this should look correct

Milan - Juve

Dida - Buffon (0 - 1)
Cafu - Zebina (1 - 0)
Stam - Thuram (1 - 1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (1 - 1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (1 - 1)
Gattuso - Emerson (1 - 1)
Pirlo - Blasi (1 - 0)
Kaka - Nedved (1 - 1)
Seedorf - Cammo (0 - 1)
Sheva - Zlatan (1 - 1)
Crespo - Del Piero/Trez (1 - 1)

I think the score is equal.

JCK · Apr 28, 2005

++ [ originally posted by Edge ] ++
Shall we do a comparison then.

Ok, made a slight error, now this should look correct

Milan - Juve

Dida - Buffon (0 - 1)
Cafu - Zebina (1 - 0)
Stam - Thuram (1 - 1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (1 - 1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (1 - 1)
Gattuso - Emerson (1 - 1)
Pirlo - Blasi (1 - 0)
Kaka - Nedved (1 - 1)
Seedorf - Cammo (0 - 1)
Sheva - Zlatan (1 - 1)
Crespo - Del Piero/Trez (1 - 1)

I think the score is equal.

Sheva is 10 fold better than Zlatan

Edge · Apr 28, 2005

I disagree, Zlatan is different type of forward to Sheva.
Sheva will always score more goals on his own, Zlatan scores fair amount and bring other players good chances too.
I think next season when Zlatan is fully settled, we will see him perform at least on a par or better than Sheva.

Lilianna · Apr 28, 2005

well,a nedved in form is better than anyone IMO!

Menace · Apr 28, 2005

zlatan has scored more then shitface

Lilianna · Apr 28, 2005

shitface is sheva??? :extatic:

oh i like it!!! :extatic::extatic:

Menace · Apr 28, 2005

Zlatan · Apr 28, 2005

IMO, this season:

Dida - Buffon (1 - 0)
Cafu - Zebina (1 - 0)
Stam - Thuram (1 - 1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (0 - 1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (1 - 1)
Gattuso - Emerson (0 - 1)
Pirlo - Blasi (1 - 0)
Kaka - Nedved (1 - 0)
Seedorf - Cammo (0 - 1)
Sheva - Zlatan (1 - 0)
Crespo - Del Piero/Trez (1 - 0)

Dan · Apr 28, 2005

I think you are being a bit generous. I would actually consider Thuram better then Stam anyway, but Nesta is superior to Canna. Zlatan dies at the hands of sheva, and its unfair to use crespo vs 2 players. Compared to both, he is better anyway. Plus, Seedorf kicks camos ass anyday.

Menace · Apr 28, 2005

how many games has stam played for milan this year 8? dont compare him to thuram its pointless

JCK · Apr 28, 2005

++ [ originally posted by Zlatan ] ++

IMO, this season:

Dida - Buffon (1 - 0)
Cafu - Zebina (1 - 0)
Stam - Thuram (1 - 1)
Nesta - Cannavaro (0 - 1)
Maldini - Zambrotta (1 - 1)
Gattuso - Emerson (0 - 1)
Pirlo - Blasi (1 - 0)
Kaka - Nedved (1 - 0)
Seedorf - Cammo (0 - 1)
Sheva - Zlatan (1 - 0)
Crespo - Del Piero/Trez (1 - 0)

This is the most reasonable comparison I have seen so far.

Menace · Apr 28, 2005

kaka better then nedved? :rolleyes:

Dan · Apr 28, 2005

I would say this season Nesta has been slightly better. However, Fabio is almost equal becuase of crucial goals he has scored.

Camo might of been a revalation this season, but is not as good as Seedorf IMO.

Zlatan · Apr 28, 2005

Eeeer, this season yes :rolleyes:

Menace · Apr 28, 2005

all kaka did this season is score lucky goals

Dan · Apr 28, 2005

All nedved did this season was lie on the sidelines.

JCK · Apr 28, 2005

And being efficient

Menace · Apr 28, 2005

same can be said about shev but you still say hes been better then zlatan

Tommason (4 Viewers)

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Biased

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Senior Member

Back &amp; Quack

Senior Member

Biased

Senior Member

Back &amp; Quack

Senior Member

Senior Member

Back &amp; Quack

Biased

Senior Member

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 4)

Back & Quack

Back & Quack

Back & Quack