Thuram???? (19 Viewers)

[HelterSkelter]

puyol made mistakes in the chelsea match and that was one of the most important matches of the season.does that make him a poor defender?

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Zlatan]

I'm sorry, but the top CB's of this world do not mistakes in the most important matches of the season..

Lazio was hardly the most important game of the season.

 

[Bjerknes]

Lazio was hardly the most important game of the season.

Did I say it was? No...dont think I did. However, the Liverpool match was last season.

 

[Eaglesnake_1]

I'm sorry, but the top CB's of this world do not mistakes in the most important matches of the season..

Oh yeah, They do, sometimes. But usually thuram performs very well in the important matches (BTW, you can not consider Lazio as an important match of the season).

 

[Zlatan]

Did I say it was? No...dont think I did. However, the Liverpool match was last season.

Thats a different issue then.

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

puyol made mistakes in the chelsea match and that was one of the most important matches of the season.does that make him a poor defender?

First, no.

Second, I don't know where I am.

Third, whz do zou not start two Cannavaro.

 

[Maher]

he is not even close to the best defender in the world, Puyol is better, and I think from seeing yesterday, Kovac is better.

agreed

 

[Maher]

I find Puyol very overrated. Andy says he doesnt make misstakes like Thuram did, but fact is I've seen him make such misstakes numrous times.

Puyol overrated?? do you see liga matches weekly??

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

Thankyou, we agree on one thing now.

 

[V]

people are overreacting. and i don't know what all the fuss is about. thuram made a stupid mistake, so what? and all of the sudden people are going he's crap, he's lost it...you don't loose your game over the night. cannavaro and thuram are the two most synchronized cbs i have ever seen play in my life. and we're doing great, top of the leauge, through in the cl, everything is going smooth as a baby's ass and now all of a sudden we draw a TOUGH match and people start panic. we've grown overconfident and this draw is a good kick to put us back on the ground.

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

No. we are NOT over-reacting.

 

[Cronios]

cannavaro and nesta is one hell of a central defence.arguably the two best defenders in the world.

Nesta does mistakes too,so us Puyol,
i bet even if we sign them,the moment they will make a mistake we will judge them worse than Materazzi

 

[Eddy]

look at cannavaro's performance in euro 2000 then talk..everyone does mistakes and were humans..we can never be perfect

 

[Holygr4le]

It was just one of those days. The whole team had their minds somewhere else.
This is my No1 worrie with capello, not beeing able to get the guys motivated. Oh, and btw, worrie No2 is that he aint capable to get them to paste up. Always so slow...

 

[giovanotti]

Yes I agree and I wrote some seconds later thet I had made mistake. I didn's say it regularly. Terry is the best. But thuram is one of the best. But he's becoming too old to play. We should buy William Gallas to replacethe Thuram.

Ok Sianco.:thumbs:

 

[giovanotti]

Cannavaro is better than Puyol Infact Canna is the best Defender in the World.

Cannavaro is better than Puyol 100%.Canna is among the best defenders,I have a special respect to Italian defenders ,because all the Italian conception of the game (since Helenio Herera's cattenacio) is totally defensive.

 

[Maher]

Cannavaro and Puyol are top defenders

 

[Bjerknes]

Oh yeah, They do, sometimes. But usually thuram performs very well in the important matches (BTW, you can not consider Lazio as an important match of the season).

I never said it was the most important match of the season...you can look back to one of the other two losses this season to find another terrible Thuram performance, and of course the said matches from last season.

But the whole point is Thuram's weakness in the air has already cost us once and will probably cost us again. Puyol is the better defender and has to cope with more pressure due to his side's style of play...I think Thuram benefits a lot from having a wall of world class defensive midfielders in front of him. Both Puyol and Cannavaro are superior..

 

[Azzurri7]

Cannavaro is better than Puyol 100%.Canna is among the best defenders,I have a special respect to Italian defenders ,because all the Italian conception of the game (since Helenio Herera's cattenacio) is totally defensive.

ayye.

 

[Adrian]

i think he is at an age where we may start seeing him decline rapidly. it happened to montero and iuliano.

i really dont think much of kovac and see thuram still being the better player.

the way i see it is that he may need replacing in the starting line up come this summer. a younger star should really be looked, so the transition of our defence is done proparly this time, unlike a few seasons back with montero and iuliano.