I still can't comprehend what special things do people see in Emerson. Even in his prime, he was slow like hell, not that tough and not even a passer (And before asking what is a passer, I said watch Pirlo and Alonso). The only good thing in Emerson is his positioning and nothing else.
By the way, I just mentioned some of the required skills in a defensive midfielder, but when it comes to a centre midfielder, Emerson is a joke.
people forget quick .. emerson turned our team around. We went from being no where near succes to champions with Emerson and Canna
Emerson gave cover to the defence and that was his job. He did it well so Nedved and Camo could start attacks
He may not be an all action mid but you don't need to be a world class sprinter or and great creative player to be a great defensive mid
Frings is not good enough to be a defensive mid here i think. maby if he was paired with a better mid and he took the offensive side of things but making him our main mid may be a mistake imo
plus next season he will be 31 why would it be smart to have him? if his ability to fight and battle are part of what makes him great at 31 and on he will be doing less and less fighting and battling
But i am not saying Frings is a bad player just not as high class as everyone says.
Trying to say he is better than Emerson is hard because as a defensive mid at bayern i think frings was not very good and could not handle criticism so he left. While Emerson has been a great DM for a long time and was even Captain of Brazil. He may not add much in attack but again .. not his job.
If we want a center mid who could add to the attack why not buy Deco? Frings seems a like we are not aiming very high.
If we want a defensive style mid we could buy Gilberto or Mavuba...
then maby pair him with frings who is ok at defence and ok at attacking ...
just my opinion though