Lol convenient BS, he didnt suck at Atalanta, but he was more of a young 2nd forward (didnt start out as poacher), he was raw but promising, not much of a goalscorer, but more of being involved in build up for them.
Viola he was bit of a chicken, scored vital goals (mainly against us) but couldnt get the time or had the nerve to fully take his game to next level, inconsistent and didnt seem to believe in himself. He did so in Samp and is defenitely good natural goalscorer, something Amauri never was and will never be.