
Welcome and thanks for the info. Glad to see you drop by. So you rate him pretty high, I suppose? Is he good enough to be a starting CB for a team competing for important trophies? Will he be suited to Serie A? How many years has he left in him (have his performances dropped with years?) Is he injury prone? Is there any chance he becomes a Boumsong in Italy? Has any other team been interested for his services during his Villa career? Why didn't any of the big teams in England show interest in him? Please discuss.
I rate him very highly, both as a person and a player. He is fairly quick for somebody who is really a CB, rarely gets troubled by pacey strikers. He's good in the air and times his tackles well. One thing that I think will help him in Serie A is that he's very composed on the ball, not likely to just panic and make a mess of things.
Whether or not he's good enough to start for a team like Juve.. I think it's a case of try it and see what happens. I personally think he could be good enough, especially when I see guys like Kaladze starting for Milan! And he's much better than him. We had Inter here as a pre-season friendly last summer, all their stars on show, Zlatan, Cruz, etc. and he had no trouble at all with them, kept Ibrahimovic quite in an easy 3-0 win. I know it's only a friendly, but he coped comfortabley.
Not injury prone, I think of his 7 seasons here, he played at least 35 games in 6 of them. Whenever he misses games it's often through illness rather than picking up an injury. I wouldn't worry about him being like Boumsong! He's 31 in September, I think, so I think he could be around for 4/5 more years with him being a defender. He's quick, but he's game isn't built on pace, so the pace he loses with age won't really affect him.
I know Valencia were after him when we were about to buy him, but other than that I'm not sure if any of Englands top teams have been in for him. There was rumours of him going to Liverpool around 2004 when Sami Hyypia (I think?) got injured, so they were looking for a replacement, nothing happened though.
I think he's very under-rated. Our other main CB, Martin Laursen, scores alot of goals, never loses a header and is very vocal, so he gets all the attention. But Mellberg is no worse of a player in my opinion. Forced to play at RB this season since we didn't have one! I don't think he'd suit Serie A at RB though as he really can't cross.
As a person he's great too. He only played 7 years for us, but made a great impression on us. One big reason is because he never hid his hatred for our big rivals Birmingham City!

But the things he did for us were fantastic - like spending all that money on shirts! Stayed loyal with us through all our bad years, and now we're back on track thanks to his help and he really deserves a shot in the Champions League, which he'll get with you!
Anyways, that'll be the end of my rant. I'm sure you'll think Mellbergs a good player once he gets started, hope it works out well for you!
