I don't even really listen to sports radio here in Boston anymore, as they have taken the 2Pac "Me against the world" line of thinking to a whole new level of absurdity, but I felt compelled to see what everyone has to say.
They are all a bunch of Janna's right now
They don't get it". And to be honest, neither do I. The way I look at this, there were a couple of mistakes here.
(#1) If Hamilton is on the market, the least you could do is create a bidding war. For the opportunity to get a 22 year old stud in the making, there would be several teams that would bid against each other to get him. We are talking about Dougie Hamilton here. And from what I heard, they wouldn't even allow Edmonton to make an offer? Really? That front office is really that mad at Chiarelli, who looks like a genius by the way considering that he held his ground on the Cam Talbot trade and got a hell of a goalie for basically a 2nd and a 3rd. I simply don't understand how you don't initiate a bidding war.
The situation is totally absurd. Obviously different, but reminds me of when O'Connell traded Thornton in the sense that the next day he was all "I had a dream last night that I traded Joe Thornton", and the rest of the GM's in the league were like, "wait, Joe Thornton was available?"
GMs usually don't give themselves a shot at a proper return on quality players if they don't let the other GM's around the league know of availability, and open it up to more offers. This is a highly coveted player, I think he could turn into a top 5-10 D-Man in the league, and if you let him go you absolutely have to get great value in return. It's gutting, bud.
Let's be clear that PC blew the Seguin trade, he made a poor calculation with the Boychuk trade, but that's not a good reason to fire the guy who helped change the culture, and was coming off a Cup, another trip to the Finals, and a President's trophy in the last 5 years. Not too shabby, not at all.
If he makes the playoffs last year, he doesn't lose his job. We're talking 2 points, and it's absolutely ludicrous. This is ego driven, eScape Goat style bullshit from on high. PC is a great GM, Edmonton is going to totally turn the corner.
#2) In my opinion, I honestly think that the front office was caught by surprise by the fact that they couldn't unload all of those draft picks to move up to get that d-man from BC. I feel that they didn't do their homework and re-organize their draft board once they realized that the trade wasn't going to happen, and they stuck to a draft board that was created BEFORE those trades were made. There were certainly better prospects they could have taken that were still on the board.
This is it, buddy. You know they had to be trying to move up to get that kid.
He tried to move up, and you're right, ducks weren't in a row. Sweeney blew it, there's no way to sugar coat that, it doesn't make any sense otherwise. I don't know the junior scene well, but working back through rankings, it does look like they were operating off a second round draft board. And I hate hearing him talk about how (to paraphrase), 'this process is all about getting the scouts excited, getting the players they want, letting them have some fun and feel rewarded for their work".
NO, DON. This process is about building a fucking balanced, competitive team, because most of the core was intact, and with a few select additions/subtractions and a little player development, this team is not that far away from being right back in contention.
Anyway, the draft is an inexact science, who knows, a few of the picks could turn out. In the meantime, though, Sweeney and, let's face it, Neely, have got a ton of work to do.