'The Broken City' (1 Viewer)

[king Ale]

If Hoori is really the D and she's protected then the Cs kill one G (Fred) and Hoori gets to investigate from tomorrow. That's already a big plus for the Cs.

If Hoori is a G and she lynches Fred, then it's gonna be 3:1 for them, which is quite good for only 2 nights. Usually the Gs go 4:0 after the first two days when everyone's confused.

I think there is no risk following her. The only problem is if Fred is a special role (detective or lawyer), but even then it's worth it.

I still don't see why would Hoori go public. I had my reasons back then because I was investigated. But I had luck Fred (the detective) to be jailed and only then I started my show.
Hoori went public out of nowhere. Even if she was investigated, how did she know who to target? I knew back then that Fred is the D becuase he played it bad and made it obvious that he's the D by attacking me. Hoori went public without being attacked.

Everything points out that she's telling the truth. The risk to trust her is worthy.

Nice try Alen and thank you for taking my side by pointing the logic in my posts, but I still know that you're a G and you're dead tomorrow

Who are you gonna investigate tomorrow?

And why should I tell you about it?

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Quetzalcoatl]

Alen stating the obvious, like a good G.

Nice try Alen and thank you for taking my side by pointing the logic in my posts, but I still know that you're a G and you're dead tomorrow

Good.

And why should I tell you about it?

Well investigate me.

 

[Osman]

I'm goind with Hoori ATM, i read the previous threads of this games. And she comes out as a manipulative person.

No one knows it more then me (in two games, one of the earliest games her and Christina fucked me and my close circle of Cs), but even ifs little to go on, its a special kind of stupid to base your suspicions on playstyle, or what role one was in ANOTHER game. That is totally irrelevant to this one.

 

[Alen]

Btw, if the jailer puts Hoori in jail, she can't be whacked. That way the BG can protect himself.

 

[king Ale]

Agreed on both accounts (your role and your suspects), I just aired the 2nd possiblity as technicality, not a probality, its 3 times more risky as a G to do what you did, then out yourself as the D. Which I wish you hadnt, even if I get it in part, the threat of whacking is somewhat little more likely with you and handful other experienced players, then with the other possibly Cs. But still, I dont like the D being known this early, you wont survive long (unless we have a good BG).


About that, The Bodyguard, take the hint and protect Hoori tonight, dont be as some others have played BG, only protect yourself all the time.

I hope it turns out to be a worthy risk.

Bodyguard has to protect me

 

[Cheesio]

No one knows it more then me (in two games, one of the earliest games her and Christina fucked me and my close circle of Cs), but even ifs little to go on, its a special kind of stupid to base your suspicions on playstyle, or what role one was in ANOTHER game. That is totally irrelevant to this one.

I changed my vote to Fred now. I'm going by the Hoori story that she's a detective. I see it as our safest bet ATM.

 

[Osman]

But just in case, the BG should not reveal his role. That way even if Hoori is lying, the BG will be safe (unless the Gs get lucky and kill him tonight).

Ofcourse, forgot there are some noobs in this game (I count some who played few games as noobs too ) and I needed to say that.

Btw, what do you think of Hoori's suspicion of you? I only read a handful of the 20 pages, so cant say much about what she is basing it on.

 

[Alen]

Btw, if the jailer puts Hoori in jail, she can't be whacked. That way the BG can protect himself.

I'm quoting this again!

 

[Alen]

Jailer, put Hoori in jail, damn you

 

[Klin]

Hoori, you went open on being the Detective far too soon for my liking.

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

Jailer, put Hoori in jail, damn you

If that happens, then there will only be 4 votes for Fred. Then you or any one or more people (G-s?) can change votes quickly to someone else and save Fred.

Do we really want her jailed? Or is it better for the BG to protect her?

 

[Osman]

I hope it turns out to be a worthy risk.

Bodyguard has to protect me

Same here, though would been nice if you waited a little with announcing this, so you could see (and rest of us in retrospect) how Fred acts like for longer, who he suspects and doesnt, says alot. I already seen few vague hints.

 

[Alen]

If that happens, then there will only be 4 votes for Fred. Then you or any one or more people (G-s?) can change votes quickly to someone else and save Fred.

Do we really want her jailed? Or is it better for the BG to protect her?

Easy. Everyone votes for Fred now. Everyone. If someone doesn't change his vote to Fred and Hoori is proven to be a detective, then we consider that person a G.

If Hoori is the detective and she is jailed, then the BG can protect himself and we have the most valuable C roles protected.

 

[king Ale]

Well investigate me.

Sure

Alen is next. If he doesn't get whacked tonight chances for him being a G are becoming even bigger

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

Easy. Everyone votes for Fred now. Everyone. If someone doesn't change his vote to Fred and Hoori is proven to be a detective, then we consider that person a G.

If Hoori is the detective and she is jailed, then the BG can protect himself and we have the most valuable C roles protected.

Okay.

TWW- Fred.

Jailer, jail Hoori. BG, protect yourself. Sounds simple enough.

 

[Alen]

Alen is next. If he doesn't get whacked tonight chances for him being a G are becoming even bigger

Just fuck off already

 

[Fake Melo]

1. King Ale - Fred
2. Melo - Fred
3. Alen - Fred
4. Cheese - Fred
5. ALC - Fred
6. Kyle - Fred
7. TWW - Fred
8. Blondu - Alen
9. Nate - Alen

10. Sab - Cheese

11. Janna - Sabsab

12. Ze Tahir - Blondu

13. Kate - Gabriel

14. Fred- Melo

 

[king Ale]

Hoori, you went open on being the Detective far too soon for my liking.

Just vote for Fred Klin

Btw, what do you think of Hoori's suspicion of you? I only read a handful of the 20 pages, so cant say much about what she is basing it on.

You have no idea what I went through. The man knows the game well and he knows that when someone claims to be the D, he/she can never be a G but he accused me of lying. Newbies were deceived and they started voting me

I was almost crying Then he changed his tone when I finally convinced people.

 

[Fake Melo]

Just fuck off already

Suspicious.

 

[Klin]

1. King Ale - Fred
2. Melo - Fred
3. Alen - Fred
4. Cheese - Fred
5. ALC - Fred
6. Kyle - Fred
7. TWW - Fred
8. Blondu - Alen
9. Nate - Alen

10. Sab - Cheese

11. Janna - Sabsab

12. Ze Tahir - Blondu

13. Kate - Gabriel

14. Fred- Melo

Has Fred justified his reason of voting for you?