Tactics and Formations (17 Viewers)

Red

-------
Moderator
Nov 26, 2006
47,024
Who would you realistically be looking to sign Red?
Dunno.

Depends on what system Juve are going to play and whether they are keeping Pirlo.

If you keep the system and keep Pirlo, you can continue as things are and just tinker.

If you ditch Pirlo and change system, you probably need to sell a big player in order to be able to commit to the change of system fully.
 

Red

-------
Moderator
Nov 26, 2006
47,024
What do you make of Menez?
I'm not a fan.

Not saying I'd dismiss the idea of signing him for free and on sensible wages completely, but he's not a player I think you can trust to consistently contribute.

I'd probably rather see Juve give Berardi a chance than see them sign Menez.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,985
As much as I dislike 3-5-2 as a system, I don't see how it can be blamed for the CL exit.

Away to Copenhagen: Created heaps of chances and conceded from a set-piece - about the only time Copenhagen made it into Juve's half.

Home to Gala: Gave away two extraordinarily stupid goals that had nothing to do with the system.

Played ~4-3-3 in the games against Real.

Home to Copenhagen: Created plenty of chances and only conceded from a set-piece.

Away to Gala: Formations fairly irrelevant in such conditions, but playing a genuine back four may have prevented Gala's goal.


So, while I'm not about to suggest 3-5-2 is a good thing or that Juve absolutely must continue using it, I don't think this season's CL failure can be blamed on it.

Juve didn't play terribly well in most of the games, but ultimately it was stupid individual errors - both in giving away goals and in missing chances - that did for them.

- - - Updated - - -

In conclusion, I think all Juve fans who dislike the 3-5-2 need to give up on them and pledge your allegiance to Aberdeen and our lovely 4-2-3-1/4-3-3.

So much pace, aggression and counter-attacking ability, while maintaing a nice balance to the team with an excellent defensive midfielder and defensive full backs.
Realistically if we wanted to stick to the 3-5-2 and implement it in Europe with an actual hope of success then we would have to make big changes.


First of all, Licht is a fantastic RB and Asamoah looks to be a dynamic, energetic CM. But NEITHER of these two players have the offensive qualities neccesary to play LWB and RWB in Europe. People will argue 'But they're defensively solid' blah blah blah etc etc.

Well we've all seen infront of our own eyes how much that's benefited us in the CL :lol:
Besides, it doesn't matter how 'defensively great' they are. Because when we need a goal and our wing backs press high up the pitch, we eventually get countered and I don't care how good you are at making a challenge, it's going to be quite difficult dispossessing the player who's 40 yards infront of you. It makes no difference basically.

So, two new attacking wing-backs. Who also put in a decent shift. Cuadrado and Criscito perhaps

Second of all, we can stick to having a Regista although i'm not a fan of this because replacing Pirlo would be like selling Vidal and hoping to find an equal replacement for him. There are none, so no matter what if we stick to a Regista we'll eventually take a dive in quality.

The better option would be to buy an attacking midfielder. That way we can still have a real creative force in the team without trying to replace the irreplacable. Makes sense to me. Of course the formation would resemble more of a 3-4-1-2 but that's minor details really

Last of all, we really do need a goal scoring machine if we're serious about mounting a challenge in Europe. Llorente or Tevez (Probably Llorente) would have to take a seat. I'm more than ok with that. Tevez might not be a real threat in Europe but he will cover a lot of ground and help take pressure off of whoever he was partnered with.


So basically, if we want to stick to 3-5-2 and improve significantly it won't be any cheaper (One could argue it would be even more expensive) than changing our system. Or... we buy another few depth players and repeat this season over & over again.
Both quality posts guys, and totally spot on on whats going on :tup:

About this:
buy an attacking midfielder
a goal scoring machine
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
and this is why im so worried about our early crash in the CL. We simply have no money for this needed changes.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,985
I wouldn't bring Berardi back this year, no way. Give him a full season at Sassuolo.
Yes.

But IMO he is a must to bring back next year. We need options and with one season in serie A under his belt, he is at minimum, ready for us in serie A.

We dont need to pamper this guys too much. They are proffesionals already, give them time to show their worth.
 

Pirlo's Beard

Junkie Joe Joyce
Oct 2, 2013
11,411
People will just say that individual defensive errors cost us

Which is true. But what about this

We never scored more than 1 goal from open play in any game, if I remember right our 2-2 with Gala had a penalty
 

Red

-------
Moderator
Nov 26, 2006
47,024
Some interesting stuff in this looking at it from a Juve perspective:

http://www.theguardian.com/football/blog/2013/dec/18/question-holding-midfielders-changing-role

The stuff about central midfielders returning to being more rounded players (rather than just destroyers or just ball players) would point to Juve being well placed, with Vidal and Pogba, to leap on the 4-2-3-1 bandwagon with the current trend.

Then there is also the observation at the end (which I believe has been brought up here before) of there not being much difference, particularly when in possession, between teams having a defensive midfielder who drops between the two central defenders, and what Juve have, with Bonucci as a permanent fixture between the other defenders.

Of course, just because there is a trend doesn't mean that one ought to try and play the same way as everyone else.

From what I've seen of Man City, who are mentioned a lot in the article, playing Toure and Fernandinho as two fairly energetic central midfielders in a 4-2-3-1 (4-4-2) the game is left so insanely open and there is such a lack of control that you would be running huge risks to play like that every week.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 14)