Summer Mercato Thread 2018 (110 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Albo

Senior Member
Apr 13, 2009
11,463
Who's better now, Kovacic or Pjanic?
Is this even serious question ?

It’s laughable to say SMS is better than Pjanic ,he might become better i dont know about it , but current Pjanic is without a doubt better than SMS .

As for Pogba,he is getting way overrated cause he won the w.c , last 2 years he was above average nothing special, Pjanic performances were better , but i guess you are good only as last your 3 games , but anyway saying Pogba is better than Pjanic i can understand even though I disagree, but comparing SMS to Pjanic :lol: :lol:


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Jul 13, 2010
6,798
Except they're not. Kovacic is more of a B2B than a regista. He is good at transitioning from defense to attack and carry the ball forward. He's also better defensively and more agile.

Pjanic has different qualities that makes him better.
of my gosh I meant to say they are not the same type and you cant really tell who is better :D I have auto correct on my phone so that goes funky sometimes
 

juve103423

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2010
949
You are comparing two different players but overalll Pjanic is definitely better
Kovacic is a great talent and you could see it right away when he played for Inter
Real bought him and I thought it was a great piece of business but I was also surprised as Real didnt buy too many Serie A youngsters back then..
Real turned him into a very good player - NOT WC YET...
He is agile he defends way better than Pjanic (who his defensive aspect really lacks IMO)
Pjanic is an organizer Kovacic is a B2B so its not easy to compare them (and not right to do it anyway)
To say Kovacic would take a team and give them a real boost in quality - Nope (He will improve them but he wont be a real difference maker)
As I see it Kovacic is a great player who can become WC but has yet to get there
Pjanic is definitely WC as what he does not many can do
Pjanic`s role is also more unique - There arent many great players in his role - The only ones I can think of are Verratti who rotates the field and the treatment table, Modric who is the goat of the organizers and please forgive me if I forget a player or two but the thing is there arent many
Its way easier to find a good B2B..
So what is this unique and very important role that we have assigned Pjanic, which makes our midfield so much better?

He can't defend as you say, but neither dribble or run. But he is definitely world class and better than SMS, Pogba and Kova
 

Orgut

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2002
19,406
So what is this unique and very important role that we have assigned Pjanic, which makes our midfield so much better?

He can't defend as you say, but neither dribble or run. But he is definitely world class and better than SMS, Pogba and Kova
What are you on?!
Who said Pjanic is better than SMS and Pogba?!
Cant defend cant dribble cant run?! Defense - Yeah he isnt the best defender - especially when you compare him to Kovacic or SMS
Cant dribble and cant run?! I never said he sucks at either of them - Kovacic is faster no doubt about it but Pjanic isnt as slow as Riquelme for example (who was a great player)

Pjanic is our organizer - he spreads the play, he provides great passes and assists, his shots arent bad as well.
The role of players like Pjanic Pirlo Verratti Modric requires different skills than the role of players like Pogba and SMS

Pjanic should not be compared to those 3 you mentioned but if you take everything and want to compare them anyway I`d say Pjanic is better than Kovacic but isnt better than Pogba or SMS
 

JUVESUPPORTER

Senior Member
Aug 25, 2003
712
OK so now we are in defensive mode. We are not buying anymore. We need to keep Pjanic and Sandro.

If we let either of these players go then the mercato has gone from fantastic (pre signing Bonnuci and letting Caladra go) to good (post signing Bonnuci) to disappointing (selling Pjanic or Sandro).

Losing Pjanic, not signing a world class midfielder, losing Caladra to bring back Bonnuci on higher wages. That will be hard to take even with Ronaldo's signing.
 

Orgut

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2002
19,406
Any Godin news? @Mark
Man Utd are interested in him but he will probably continue his adventure with Atletico..
Ohh you meant Juve?! Dont expect anything we are done..
The only transfers you could still see are
1. Sales
2. Small purchases like youngsters
3. Big purchases like SMS (only in case Pjanic leaves) or Marcelo (only in case A.Sandro leaves) both unlikely

- - - Updated - - -

OK so now we are in defensive mode. We are not buying anymore. We need to keep Pjanic and Sandro.

If we let either of these players go then the mercato has gone from fantastic (pre signing Bonnuci and letting Caladra go) to good (post signing Bonnuci) to disappointing (selling Pjanic or Sandro).

Losing Pjanic, not signing a world class midfielder, losing Caladra to bring back Bonnuci on higher wages. That will be hard to take even with Ronaldo's signing.
If we sell Pjanic - One of Pogba/SMS will surely arrive (due to the fact the EPL window is almost closed I`d say its SMS) so dont worry we will have a WC CM anyway
 
Jul 20, 2012
20,044
Romeo agresti says unless we sell Pjanic or Sandro mercato closed.

Also we will play with 3 at the back.

3-5-2 or 3-4-3?
A 3-4-3 could be interesting with

Sandro - Maituidi/Can - Pjanic - Cancelo

In the midfield but I'd much rather a 4-3-3

- - - Updated - - -

Romeo agresti says unless we sell Pjanic or Sandro mercato closed.

Also we will play with 3 at the back.

3-5-2 or 3-4-3?
A 3-4-3 could be interesting with

Sandro - Maituidi/Can - Pjanic - Cancelo

In the midfield but I'd much rather a 4-3-3
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 109)