Its not about DM which some here suggest - Its about finding a suitable partner for Pjanic!
AMR - Bernardeschi/D.Costa/Cuadrado
AMC - Dybala/Bernardeschi/Probably Keita/Pjaca
AML - Bernardeschi/D.Costa/Pjaca/Mandzukic/probably Keita
Considering D.Costa potential and the Bernardeschi expectations we need no more AMs...
CM is what we need but we need someone who compliment Pjanic - Pjanic is a player that can create while he isnt the best defender/header/strength which is why we need someone who can offer this
SMS is a player that attack and defend while he is good in the air and not a player that is pushed around easily - This is why I think he would fit!
Matic is a player that is strong physically + good in the air and defends well so he fits the bill (even if he isnt my favorite as I want the player to be able to attack better)
We dont necessarily need a destroyer.. a box to box could fit as well if he has the right characteristics...
Goretka is not a dm - He is actually more of an AM than DM but he is good in the air and isnt powered out easily + he can defend so he could have been a brilliant coup (unfortunately Bayern probably has him in the bag)
We don't need another box to box player, box to box players are all around players than can do both as you said, but the 4-2-3-1 cannot host them in the front 3. The side front 2 must be wide players, so that our formation doesn't choke in the middle, yet the position I called CAM and you called AMC, is not meant for a box to box player, because he will be covered by the two DMs behind him and will be flanked by the two wingers, this position will be charged to create chances, the final pass and many times even finish!
that's why we are using a SS, an AMF also fits, but we only have Bernar, who is primarily a winger and will be used as such, esp considering we need two. This is the position we don't have options.
The SMS characteristic s you have described can be found in abundance in our 8 CMs, would qualities a player like Magic would bring that are not already there. Better quality yes, but not different characteristic s.
Marchisio imo has more offensive characteristics than Magic, as he has a decent long shoot, Asamoah is fast and strong, Khedira more experienced and calm under pressure.
Unless we sell 2 at least of Sturaro, Lemina and Rincon, the last thing we need is yet another DM...
In our 3-5-2 formation, we used to stack CMs ,able to offer all-round performance and a lot of them, because we need 3 of them fielded at all times. They had the characteristic needed to complement each other.
Now we only need 2 of them and the player who plays ahead of them must have the offensive characteristics they don't have.Neither does Matic, or Matuidi...