Summer mercato thread 2017-18 (255 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,657
Let me get this straight.

N'zonzi cant have domminated the midfield if :

- WS score isnt high.
- Barcelona won the game


And

1-2 is getting smashed



This is why no one takes you serious Hist.

- - - Updated - - -



All we needed against Madrid is the bench to have allowed our starters to play 90 minutes instead of 45.

You and PI are basically saying the same. Fix the midfield and get more decisive options from the bench.
Nice selectivity here where you focus only on the closest encounter with barca and not all the bigger smashings. I added the WS ratings to show that he didnt individually have a good game even if his team did relatively well in that match despite losing.

If you see a player having a good game individually in a losing team, then we'd expect his individual rating to be high. Check his rating against madrid in the UEFA super cup final where they lost 3-2.. that can be a case of him having a great game despite the team losing.

And you conveniently ignored the point that EVEN if we grant that he had an okay game in that 2-1 loss to barca, that does not mean he is an ELITE player.

You need a LOT more evidence to show he DOMINATED (thats a strong word) that game and then to claim the even more distant conclusion that he is an ELITE player.

- - - Updated - - -

lol for real? gtfo @Hist

- - - Updated - - -



even that would make more sense that whoscored

- - - Updated - - -



is Rode better than Rico? i wonder
Its not the best of metrics but it is an indicator. Its not like they flip a coin and assign a random number. Find me a better rating system to judge individual performances in that game and if he gets a rating that shows he dominated that game then I will concede the point that he dominated one game against barca.

I am giving some (admittedly imperfect) evidence that he didnt do well. You/zack have given none.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 254)