He would be perfect for both roles, but too expensive for backup role. He is good enough to bench Cuadrado, that is if we didnt have an AM like Dybala but different type. He is pretty similar in style to Dybala, would be kinda odd to see them drift to same areas.
He wont be a backup lol.. He would be a starter but not a regular one as he will rotate with Cuadrado to maintain form&both could rest a bit.. He would fill in for Dybala when needed...
For example we start Silva Dybala LW and then we decide to sub Dybala->Silva will take his place and Cuad will take Silva`s role... He would be a very good buy
Honestly if he costs over 50M we could also go for James who can play LW and AM which means he will take Mandzukic role which is better IMO
Our weakest position IMO is LW where we have Mandzukic who is a very good player but not really a WC winger... Cuad really developed and seems to making a more reasonable decisions...
Honestly both could be upgraded as Cuad lacks 2 things in his game: 1. being deadly 2. have that smart key passes
Mandzukic has lots of abilities but not ones of a proper winger which help us and hurt us at the same time...
Mandzukic is definitely more deadly than Cuad but we can improve on that as well + We can get someone who is far better at dribbling - Lemar could be a very good option given his skill set and age. He is not the only option of course but we can definitely use some interesting wingers
Pjaca - Very talented but seems like an injury prone player and we cant just rely on him..
- - - Updated - - -
My priorities would be:
-Attacking Midfielder
-Left Footed Winger
-Right Fullback
-Defensive Midfielder
We achieve that with 3 players:
-Lemar (LM/LAM)
-James (CAM/SS)
-Fabinho (CDM/RB)
Fabinho to me is a must-sign. We're weak in both RB for the future, and CDM. He can play both positions splendidly.
If we get Lemar it would be better to get Silva with him as I cant see James or Lemar play on the right...
As for Fabinho - Im definitely a fan but he seems more of a CDM than a RB at Monaco - How many games did he play RB there?