Striker rating? (1 Viewer)

Martin

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2000
56,810
#1
Ok, we have Ale, Trez, Salas, Zalayeta, Di Vaio. And we know that Trez is probably going to be injured for a few months, so who's the guy to fill in? How would you rate the forwards?

In a two-man strike force, Del Piero is hardly under threat of losing his place as long as he stays fit. Trez, given his scoring rate, would fill the second spot. But if not Trez, would you take Salas or Di Vaio? Assuming Del Piero is fit, it would probably be between Salas and Di Vaio.

If Del Piero were injured, that would probably make Salas his replacement and Trez with Di Vaio for the role of pure striker.

Support striker:
1. Del Piero
2. Salas

Hitman:
1. Trezeguet
2. Salas
3. Di Vaio
4. Zalayeta
 

denco

Superior Being
Jul 12, 2002
4,679
#2
If Trez is not playing i will opt for them to use Di Vaio and Dp as the strike force as he is more in form than Salas is

But if Dp is the one thats unfit i would rather they played with

Trez, Salas and Di vaio with Salas and Di Vaio either side of Trez
 
Aug 20, 2002
141
#4
Really Respaul do u think that di vaio - Dp will work better than Trez - Dp

Actually having thought about it i think u might be right as di vaio will work harder than trez and run more off the ball.

we could play
--------------------Di Vaio-------Trez-----------------------
-------------------------------Dp------------------------------

Does anyone think this could work

P.s I think we should sell Salas sooner rather than later and give Olivera (spelling maybe wrong) a chance because by the sounds of it he could be great.
 

Reza

Junior Member
Jul 13, 2002
266
#5
i heard that trez is out for 5 months so we have not any sricker that hit the target like that way tez does.
 

Respaul

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2002
4,734
#7
I dont think Di Vaio is particurly selfish...
But thats still better than playing with ten men till you put the ball in the box for trez... at least di vaio makes a contribution.

Trez may well be one of the best finnishers in the game but he is also the most non contributive player i have ever seen.
 

Sivori

Senior Member
Jul 17, 2002
810
#8
Yeah, say what you want about Pippo Inzaghi but he atleast fought for every ball and ran to stress the defenders and goalkeepers. In a 50-50 situation he is way more likely to put in his all than trezegol.
 

Stu

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2002
17,543
#9
With no injuries I would opt for a 3 man's attack with Di Vaio,Trezeguet and Del Piero. My reason for this is simply that DV/Treze are too good to occupy a place on the substitutes bench,while DP is the soul of Juve and is untouchable unless he is not fit. Even when he is not 100% fit,he can still be a dangerous threat.

With our current injuries,Di Vaio will partner Del Piero. If DP is out of action,Salas will partner DV.

Who should partner DP in a 2 man's strike force you ask? I have to say Di Vaio. Both DV and Treze are outstanding strikers,but the former is the best man to partner Del Piero. Marco is faster and more skilful with the ball at his feet. Maybe he is not as good as Trezeguet inside the penalty area,but if he's good enough to net 20 goals in Serie A he has to be good enough.

Without any injuries this is my starting lineup :

Buffon - Thuram,Tudor,Montero,Pessotto - Zambrotta,Tacchinardi,Davids - Nedved - Di Vaio,Del Piero
 

Stu

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2002
17,543
#10
About my starting lineup,I would love to have Treze in it,but with 3 strikers and Nedved that would leave us unbalanced,that is why I opted for a 4-3-1-2.
 

K10

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2002
2,698
#11
++ [ originally posted by Alex ] ++
Ok, we have Ale, Trez, Salas, Zalayeta, Di Vaio. And we know that Trez is probably going to be injured for a few months, so who's the guy to fill in? How would you rate the forwards?

In a two-man strike force, Del Piero is hardly under threat of losing his place as long as he stays fit. Trez, given his scoring rate, would fill the second spot. But if not Trez, would you take Salas or Di Vaio? Assuming Del Piero is fit, it would probably be between Salas and Di Vaio.

If Del Piero were injured, that would probably make Salas his replacement and Trez with Di Vaio for the role of pure striker.

Support striker:
1. Del Piero
2. Salas

Hitman:
1. Trezeguet
2. Salas
3. Di Vaio
4. Zalayeta
From being afraid of having a weak attack with bearly any strikers to an attack which is hard to choose.

Salas is very capable of taking the goal scoring role when he is ready. Well, so is Di Vaio, Trez and yes, even Zalayeta.

If it were me, I would rotate the strikers every game. They are too class to be a sub for one another. Even Zalayeta.
 

Febrina

Senior Member
Jul 17, 2002
2,011
#12
++ [ originally posted by respaul ] ++
All players fit: Di vaio - Ale

Trez injured: No Change

Di Vaio injured : Trez - Ale

Ale injured: Di Vaio - Salas
So, Trez and Di Vaio couldn't play together then?
 

Tom

The DJ
Oct 30, 2001
11,726
#13
------------------------Buffon-------------------------

----Thuram---------Montero---------Tudor--------

Zamby--------------Davids-----------------Nedved

----------------------DelPiero-------------------------

----Salas-------------Trez------------DiVaio--------

play this if we need goals!
 

Febrina

Senior Member
Jul 17, 2002
2,011
#14
Ehem...4 strikers! Not bad!

what about this one:

--------------------------------Buffon

---------Thuram-------------Montero--------------Iuliano----------

---------------------------------Tudor------------------------------------

--------Zambro/---------Baiocco----------Davids-----------Nedved
Camonaresi

------------------------------------------------Ale/Di Vaio---------------

---------------------------------Salas/Trez------------------------------

I think it's more save ;)
 

Stu

Senior Member
Jul 14, 2002
17,543
#15
++ [ originally posted by Paolo_Montero ] ++
------------------------Buffon-------------------------

----Thuram---------Montero---------Tudor--------

Zamby--------------Davids-----------------Nedved

----------------------DelPiero-------------------------

----Salas-------------Trez------------DiVaio--------

play this if we need goals!
Nah,can't work. Too risky. If we NEED goals then I would go for a 3-4-3.

Buffon - Thuram,Tudor,Montero - Zambrotta,Tacchinardi,Davids,Nedved - Di Vaio,Trezeguet,Del Piero
 

Tom

The DJ
Oct 30, 2001
11,726
#16
And if we are away to real madrid...

---------------------------Buffon-------------------------

--------------------------Montero------------------------
Thuram---------Tudor-----------Iuliano-----Pessotto

Zambrotta---Tacchinardi----Davids---------Nedved


-----------------------------Trez--------------------------

Can't get much more safe than this lol!
 

Slagathor

Bedpan racing champion
Jul 25, 2001
22,708
#17
If we are away to Real Madrid:

----------------------buffon------------------

--Ferrara--------Montero------Pessotto--
--Thuram----------Tudor----------Iuliano--

--Zambrotta------Davids------Nedved--

-------------------Del Piero--------------

:D
 
Aug 21, 2002
44
#19
Is di Vaio more of a supporting striker like DP or a target man like Trez? Coz from what i've seen imo his has good dribbling ability, quite versatile, like to go deep to get the ball some times and can deliver good if not great crosses!

So i see him more like DP really, not trez.. only far more lethal maybe!

Can someone explain this 2 me?
 

Majed

Senior Member
Jul 17, 2002
9,630
#20
++ [ originally posted by ErikP ] ++
If we are away to Real Madrid:

----------------------buffon------------------

--Ferrara--------Montero------Pessotto--
--Thuram----------Tudor----------Iuliano--

--Zambrotta------Davids------Nedved--

-------------------Del Piero--------------

:D
:LOL: I dont think its enough for and Away Real Madrid game, mayeb this might stop them?!:

--------------------Buffon--&--Chimenty--------------------

----------------------Ferrara--Montero--------------------
Bierindelli--Thuram--Tudor---Iuliano--Fresi_Pessotto

-----------------------------Davids:fero:-------------------------

;-)
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)