Yes and no.
The results he's with the players at his disposal are phenomenal.
When you watch the games, though, you can't help but feel that he is simply making a mockery of modern football.
If teams went back to old-fashioned basics like having defenders who could be relied on to concentrate and using actual wingers to stretch a game out (instead these inward-looking wide players who just allow Atletico to crowd the middle of the pitch), I suspect Atletico would be shown to be what they are - a good, solid side, but nothing out of what should be ordinary.