Buffon: 4.5 - had nothing to do during the match, then decided to try a stupid dribble that could have cost us 2 points. An experienced player like him should know better. I'm subtracting points simply because of who he is.
Lichsteiner: 6 - did what he needed to do. Can't fault him for not linking up well with Giacch, who was useless. Put in more useful crosses than him too.
Barzagli: 6.5 - has started the season pretty well. Had a bit of a slip-up but made up for it.
Chiellini: 5.5 - was doing ok until he got injured. Hope it's not too serious.
Grosso: 6 - surprisingly good. No mistakes in defence and actually emphasised how bad Pepe was.
Giaccherini: 4 - simply shouldn't be playing for us. Even his pass that led to Vucinic's assist wasn't very good. He's too weak and lacks creativity.
Marchisio: 3 - Very very poor. I don't remember seeing a useful tackle or pass the whole match.
Pirlo: 5.5 - was surrounded by schmucks, but had some moments of class.
Pepe: 4 - I really don't understand why people keep defending this guy. He's got some pace and works hard, but has absolutely no skill. Probably the most frustrating player to watch.
Vucinic: 5.5 - was generally pretty poor, but he didn't get much service after all, and actually did really well to set up the goal, so extra marks.
Matri: 5.5 - hard to blame him since he's a target man, but he's not good enough to get involved in build up play. Well taken goal though.
Vidal: 6.5 - absolute beast. Was all over the place making tackles and interceptions. Watch and learn, Claudio.
Del Piero: 5 - should have had an assist to either Vidal or Pepe, but waited too long to pass it off, although Vidal should have done a lot better.
Bonucci: 5 - didn't do much, but showed that he doesn't have the composure to be the world class CB that we need.
Conte: 4 - poorly chosen starting lineup, and left himself in a position where he needed to make 4 or 5 subs. He took way too long to make replacements, and I never want to see Giacch and Pepe starting together again.