Well, we're going to look fondly at Livorno this season. But the way this match started, it wasn't that clear. The match was won because Juve capitalized on some great passing from Zanetti that sprung attackers from distance and proved to be accurate, and our forwards finished enough to make it count.
On the downside, the defense was often playing like the Keystone Cops -- looking disorganized, with missed assignments, and leaving major gaps. Belardi's first real start for us wasn't marred too badly by it, but we weren't helping it either. Two matches in a row against 10-man squads, and we still seem to look like we need defensive help.
Otherwise, offensively we seemed to show a lot better coordination.
Belardi - 6.5 - Generally on the mark, despite the lack of help at times. The one free kick from Tavano that luckily rebounded off the post was a good example -- he played close enough to the post to reach, but didn't overplay it to leave him as exposed on the other side. Not a bad start when trying to fill Gigi's shoes and not having a rhythm with the team yet.
Salihamidzic - 4.5 - Downright awful today. Most of his crosses were deflected and couldn't make it through. The ones that weren't blocked would only make contact with the beer vendors. And defensively, he exposed us far too often. Which isn't so bad when you're on the attack a lot. But when you're passing to the wrong guy up the pitch, at least come back and defend and not stand there when he screams by you in the other direction.
Grygera - 5.5 - I have mixed feelings here. He's clearly not in a position he's comfortable with. He seems too small for the role and generally looks pretty lost out there. But he's playing a role the team needs and, well, he wasn't terrible at it (see: Brazzo). A few decent headers off the line, but trouble the whole time.
Legrottaglie - 6 - Still our most confident defender. But that wasn't rubbing off on his teammates. The good news is that his individual play has become strong enough that we can be confident in him. The bad news is that he's the best we have in defense right now, and we need more leadership and organization from him that we're not getting in matches like this.
Molinaro - 6.5 - You can't always be sure what you get from this guy from game to game. A couple of defensive errors, but this was perhaps his best defensive match as a juventino yet. Twice in the first half he ran down breakaway plays of a charging Livorno counterattack. The first time, he sped up and took away the inside option to prevent a galloping Pasquale from passing at the end of the counterattack, forcing him to take the shot at Belardi instead...and then he ended up clearing the resulting ball that came back on the volley. The second time before the end of the half, he completely cut off a galloping Tristan on the counterattack -- coming from behind and sweeping the ball out from right in front of the guy.
Our fastest guy on defense, it seems. And some strong play there. Offensively, he loses the ball under pressure too easily, but a couple of nice plays inside -- including his early cross to Nedved.
Unlike the good-play-then-disaster of Boumsong, I'm still not sure what to make of Molinaro. He's young and seems to be developing/improving in some areas -- which is a lot more than I can say for Grygera where it's clear he's as good as he will ever be for us. The verdict is still out if this guy will come through as a future starter or will fall back in the laughable dust bin.
Palladino - 6 - Another thing clear to me from this match was that Palladino will never be a worthy Juve starter in attack. He just doesn't have the finishing skills or instincts for that. But he does have good ball skills on the wing and some in midfield. He's an assist man and not a goal man.
Nocerino - 5.5 - Great pursuit, but could have been more effective in results. Also came apart a lot late in the second half when we were not winning balls when defending against an attacking 10-man side.
C Zanetti - 8 - Some of the best ball of his career, perhaps? MOM. Brilliant looping passes that accurately target attackers on the run. Heads-up play and excellent service from afar. Not every one of his brilliant passes were converted today, but just enough of them. And even decent coverage in defense on the counter.
Nedved - 6 - Some decent movement in attack, but it didn't result in much on the board.
Del Piero - 7 - Some sloppy possession here and there: a running drive to an easy tackle that takes him out and sends the ball the other way and him to the ground. Or meddling with the ball for too long when he had the charge and the numbers advantage. But classic Del Piero creativity at his feet, a great counterattack goal, and perfect pairing with his assist on Trez's second goal.
Trezeguet - 7.5 - Classic Trez special today: a few touches, but when we needed it he was one-touch deadly. Caught him too often on the wings trying to slow down a wayward upfield pass when we needed him in the goal box. But otherwise very, very fine form today. Excellent sense of the defensive line and being onsides today.
Subs:
Iaquinta - 5.5 - On the pitch long enough to make an impact, but didn't.
Castiglia - 6 - On for so very brief, but I liked what I saw. Got involved and passed well with his teammates.
Coach:
Ranieri - 5 - The team won in spite of his tactics. Defense was disorganized. We were on the ropes for too long against a 10-man Livorno. This team won from the brilliance of Zanetti and enough good play and finishing from Del Piero and Trezeguet to put it out of reach for the opportunities we made.