I never said otherwise. I wouldn't use words like phenomenal or amazing though. JJ has been starved of quality mids for years now, so someone who does things right consistently is now considered a savior. I understand. It's like going to fight off in a war and not seeing pussy for years.
Fagiot has been consistent and efficient, but he's no superstar, yet he commands/demands superstar wages.
If he agrees to 5 million a year for two seasons, then you renew him. Anything beyond that is a monumental risk.