Terrible.
Starting with Marchisio on the left, we all knew he couldn't, we have Giovinco who can, and Ciro plays Claudio. He isn't in the game, does jack shit for the time he is on and we're 1-0 down. Giovinco in the minutes he played did ten times more than anyone did on either flank. Then Camoranesi who was also awful, and nothing like what we saw a few weeks back. Very inconsistent.
In defense, Molinaro wasn't only what we expected, but much worse. Cagliari's pace highlighted the issues we will have with Cannavaro if he insists on going in for a challenge instead of holding back and we concede two (beautiful) goals, and I'm slightly reminded of Buffon vs Lecce last season.
Amauri produced a yellow card for himself, and was generally awful in everything he did. He thinks he's Maradona or something with the way he attempts to dribble past 3 defenders before scoring, and he can't make it past one of those bodies. He doesn't control the ball or try fancy footwork, but we see that Trezeguet offers the team so much more.
The amount of work Diego does around the area is really sad when nobody is pulling their thumb out. I expect him to get bashed for free kicks/wasting possession/whatever, and a little of it is deserved, but no way can he do it all himself. Del Piero came on and we saw a bit better, and we played our best football for the last 5 minutes when we were already 2-0 down. Him, Cáceres and Chiellini get pass marks.