Serie A 2017/18 (12 Viewers)
- Thread starter Azzurri7
- Start date
- Status
And you clearly haven't a clue how the handball rule is actually applied. 90% of handballs are accidental. It's rare players actually try to block the ball with their arm. Unless the arm is tight to the body, handball is pretty much always given. His arm is up and out from his body. That's the only reason the ball hits it. And the only reason the ball goes in. It's natural to jump by throwing one's hands up into the air, but if you hit the ball with your hand above your head it's whistled. Always. It's that Simple.
Who the fuck cares though. I'm laughing at how useless VAR is. And you come alone with another retarded opinion.
Ignore.
Who the fuck cares though. I'm laughing at how useless VAR is. And you come alone with another retarded opinion.
Ignore.
So his arm is in a natural position then
Player has shown no intent to handle the ball
It can not be a foul if that's the case
your arms will never be by your side if you are heading the ball
it was an accidental handball and his positioning of the arms were natural
It can't be anymore black and white than that and if you think otherwise you don't understand the rules of the game
Player has shown no intent to handle the ball
It can not be a foul if that's the case
your arms will never be by your side if you are heading the ball
it was an accidental handball and his positioning of the arms were natural
It can't be anymore black and white than that and if you think otherwise you don't understand the rules of the game
Vialli_92 actually got a legit point. It isn't ludacris to argue that it is a legit goal, altho I'd say it isn't due to the bend of the arm as well as the long travelling tiem from the cross. It's a decision down to the referees estimate of the following
https://football-technology.fifa.com/media/1245/lotg_17_18_en.pdf
- - - Updated - - -
Argument from authority is a common fallacy, Mark.
https://football-technology.fifa.com/media/1245/lotg_17_18_en.pdf
- - - Updated - - -
Gattuso doesn't know the rules then also. Cool. 
The point is that if this is seen, it's always called handball. That's how the rule is applied. I can jump higher by throwing my hands up over my head. However if I punch the ball while doing so, it's a handball.
It's your responsibility to keep your arms in by your body. Which is why defenders don't put their arms out into the air while jumping to defend setpieces. There are lots of times arms extended from the body are natural while moving around, but if it touches the ball it is handball anyways. The "natural position" thing is silly. Any time the arm is out from the body refs call it an unnatural position. That term literally only means arm out from body when practically applied.
Cutrone's goal should have been disallowed. It wouldn't have gone in without his extended arm directing it in. It's that simple.
It's your responsibility to keep your arms in by your body. Which is why defenders don't put their arms out into the air while jumping to defend setpieces. There are lots of times arms extended from the body are natural while moving around, but if it touches the ball it is handball anyways. The "natural position" thing is silly. Any time the arm is out from the body refs call it an unnatural position. That term literally only means arm out from body when practically applied.
Cutrone's goal should have been disallowed. It wouldn't have gone in without his extended arm directing it in. It's that simple.
The guy is ridiculous. 
The natural position thing is the most ambiguous statement ever. What's a natural arm position? In moving around, running, etc, the arms constantly move out from the body. For the sport of futbol an unnatural position is interpreted as arm extended out from the body. Players are expected not to handle the ball by keeping arms tight to the body. If they handle with arm extended, it's always whistled if seen.
The natural position thing is the most ambiguous statement ever. What's a natural arm position? In moving around, running, etc, the arms constantly move out from the body. For the sport of futbol an unnatural position is interpreted as arm extended out from the body. Players are expected not to handle the ball by keeping arms tight to the body. If they handle with arm extended, it's always whistled if seen.
opinion of ex refs don't matter then?
http://www.lucamarelli.it/22esima-giornata-domenica-dimenticare/
http://www.lucamarelli.it/22esima-giornata-domenica-dimenticare/
The guy is ridiculous.
The natural position thing is the most ambiguous statement ever. What's a natural arm position? In moving around, running, etc, the arms constantly move out from the body. For the sport of futbol an unnatural position is interpreted as arm extended out from the body. Players are expected not to handle the ball by keeping arms tight to the body. If they handle with arm extended, it's always whistled if seen.
The natural position thing is the most ambiguous statement ever. What's a natural arm position? In moving around, running, etc, the arms constantly move out from the body. For the sport of futbol an unnatural position is interpreted as arm extended out from the body. Players are expected not to handle the ball by keeping arms tight to the body. If they handle with arm extended, it's always whistled if seen.
Definition of "natural"
"If you say that it is natural for someone to act in a particular way or for something to happen in that way, you mean that it is reasonable in the circumstances."
In this case it was natural for his arms to be raised to head the ball for balance purposes
- - - Updated - - -
"after seeing the episode countless times, the feeling is that the deviation was carried out with the arm and that, therefore, the network should have been canceled."
He fails to account for the rules and assumes because it touched his arm it's a foul he doens't give any reason to why it's a foul other than it touched his arm and is ignoring the rules
The guy is ridiculous.
The natural position thing is the most ambiguous statement ever. What's a natural arm position? In moving around, running, etc, the arms constantly move out from the body. For the sport of futbol an unnatural position is interpreted as arm extended out from the body. Players are expected not to handle the ball by keeping arms tight to the body. If they handle with arm extended, it's always whistled if seen.
The natural position thing is the most ambiguous statement ever. What's a natural arm position? In moving around, running, etc, the arms constantly move out from the body. For the sport of futbol an unnatural position is interpreted as arm extended out from the body. Players are expected not to handle the ball by keeping arms tight to the body. If they handle with arm extended, it's always whistled if seen.
- Status