i simply pointed out mcgrain as an example,i never made the link of celtic men meaning a catholic. perhaps i am a little naive that the thought did not cross my mind when i wrote that phrase that it may be perceived as a bigoted comment
OK, no problem...I accept you didn't mean this as it is possible that you didn't realise
it is rather unfortunate that the general public immediately make the connection of religious denomination simple with the club you support,however the old firm did trade on religious segregation for many years. it may well take years for both sets to distance themselves from the bigotry that ahs blighted scotland for far too long
I've heard this argument many times before, mostly from the Press...but I dont think you can actually state that Celtic Football Club itself actually traded or perpetuated religious segregation...the bigoted section of the fans yes, by all means...but club itself, no...if you have something in mind point it out so that I can consider it and respond, but I believe that's it's always been the fans, man...never the club...hence a vast support from non-catholics from the early days who followed Celtic for footballing reasons only without any thought about religious conotations
I think another step in the right direction would be for fans of non-old firms clubs to stop pushing the concept that the religious thingy is only connected to Celtic and Rangers...although indeed a bigger problem in this part of the world, it's not just a west coast problem...just a question of degrees
as for the minority of hearts fans that do jump on the bandwagon-it is embarrassing personally to hear them sing songs that shame both sets of religions. for me the only thing worse is the "big jock knew" brigade,why anyone would think it is big,clever or funny is beyond me
it is pretty obvious to anyone reading the last few posts that you thought i meant one thing and directed an "orange joke" in the direction of the club i support as some sort of retort. i was trying to make a valid point and you resorted to name calling in a rather sleekit way. i have a problem trying to get across that there is a vocal minority that shame my club, but they are just that, a minority
a perfect example of my reply above...a minority, but it still exists...but not readily acknowledged...and as for sleekit, if I think your a d*ck, have insulted me or my club, I'll write it out plain to see, - in capitals - no need for being sleekit - I've been here for eight years, held my own against the high and mighty, the old hands will tell you I try to be fair, but will let you know big time if I'm displeased, not my style.
and are the bigots at the old firm the vocal minority or a majority that shame their clubs? What % is acceptable before Hearts can be considered to have a problem? I'm not comming down hard on you in any way as you acknowledge it exists and what you write is positive about the issue, unlike the blinkered fans who ignore this and pretend it's the old firm that's responsible for all the woes of Scottish Football...I just want to know your opinion
oh don't get me wrong i know that the popular conception of all old firm fans is this way but most fans of the old firm i know really could not give two shits about religion, as with hearts and hibs fans. maybe in time that will become the more common conception, but i doubt it will be in our lifetimes
What you say is correct, so why don't non-bigots of non-old firm clubs readily accept this rather than going on, and on, and on, and o...about this issue instead of looking inwards in an attempt to solve their own clubs problems? I actually respect Rangers fans more that any other club in Scotland on this subject, as they at least don't pretend it doesn't exist within their fans and doesn't need addressing...out of curiosity, what do Hearts actively do to address this minority, lifetime bans, etc?...just want to know..
anyway moving on, i think that is strach is trying to get the fans on side the re-signing of shaun maloney may be just the trick, though fan pressure probably would have seen the move go ahead anyway. it really could eb an inspired signing for celts and gives them a lot more flexibility and firepower
personally I would punt McGeady for as much as possible now...he's sussed